If you’re buying an electrical appliance from a major Australian retailer this Black Friday, chances are you’ll be offered an extended warranty.
An extended warranty covers your product for longer than the manufacturer or retailer’s free voluntary warranty. It can cost up to around 20% of what you paid for your product, depending on the store and duration of the warranty.
While an extended warranty may sound like a good idea, your rights under the Australian Consumer Law (ACL) generally entitles you to a repair, refund or a replacement within a reasonable time after purchase if your product stops working properly, and these rights are available alongside any regular warranty.
When you’re spending a lot on new purchases, it can be tempting to opt into an extended warranty.
Unfortunately, many shoppers don’t know this – a fact that retailers often exploit to sell you an extended warranty that you don’t need in order to increase their profits.
So if you’re already covered by the ACL, do costly extended warranties offer any real value?
We look at retailers’ sales techniques, and compare any extra “benefits” they spruik with the current consumer law protections.
Your Australian Consumer Law rights: What you need to know
Under the ACL, you generally have a right to a refund, repair or replacement (collectively known as remedies) if your product does not work as intended, develops a fault or is unsafe.
If the failure (or problem) is “minor”, the retailer can decide to repair or replace your product. If it’s “major”, you can choose between a replacement, a refund, or keeping the product and being compensated for its loss in value. Under the ACL, any replacement or repaired product continues to be covered.
Extended warranties, however, may only offer limited remedies, such as either a one-off replacement or a one-off repair.
Extended warranties will often cover costs like shipping a faulty product back to the store, or things like food spoilage or laundry costs from a broken fridge or washing machine. But these things are also generally covered by the ACL.
Importantly, these rights under the ACL, also known as consumer guarantees, are available to you free of charge. And you can seek a remedy under the ACL even if you have bought an extended warranty.
In 2022, CHOICE ran an investigation where we posed as a potential customer and called 80 Harvey Norman, JB Hi-Fi and The Good Guys stores across the country.
We asked their staff what our rights were if a product we bought developed a fault outside the warranty period. Our investigation found that 71% of stores misrepresented our consumer rights.
The investigation found that 71% of stores misrepresented our consumer rights
The most common misrepresentation was staff stating or implying that there was little to no chance of receiving a free remedy after the warranty expired. The vast majority of salespeople (91%) tried to sell us an extended warranty when we asked about consumer rights.
Consumer law provides similar or better coverage than extended warranties
A spokesperson from the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) told CHOICE that customers should be “cautious about purchasing extended warranties, which may not offer any additional benefits to what is automatically provided under the ACL”.
The ACCC recommends consumers ask the business what its extended warranty provides over and above their automatic rights, and read the terms and conditions to understand if the warranty offers any additional benefits.
Terms and conditions for extended warranties should be available on retailers’ websites, and often display a comparison of what warranties and your automatic rights both provide.
The ACCC recommends consumers ask the business what its extended warranty provides over and above their automatic rights
What this usually reveals is that if your product is covered by consumer guarantees under the ACL, in most cases it renders extended warranties unnecessary.
Retailers openly state this in their product information.
“Your JB Hi-Fi Minimum Voluntary Warranty Period and your ACL rights generally provide protection longer than the standard manufacturer’s warranty without the need for any extended warranty,” JB Hi-Fi’s Extra Care brochure reads.
Officeworks’ and Bing Lee’s extended warranty brochures explain that your rights under ACL “may continue even at the expiry of the Manufacturer’s warranty for the goods or the [extended warranty]”.
The extra warranty ‘benefits’ retailers try to sell you
Retailers aren’t allowed to say their extended warranties offer better coverage than the ACL when this is not the case, so they often spruik other supposed benefits to market these products to shoppers.
We break down some of these claims and see if they stack up against reality and your consumer law rights.
‘Benefit’ #1: ‘Certainty’ about how long your product is covered
The claim: Businesses such as JB Hi-Fi, The Good Guys, Harvey Norman, Officeworks and Bing Lee all claim that compared to the ACL, their products provide “certainty” as to the exact period of cover.
The reality: Under the ACL, you can seek a remedy for a faulty product within a reasonable period after the date of purchase or delivery. What a “reasonable” time might be can depend on the quality and price of the product, and how it was used.
CHOICE director of consumer impact Andy Kelly says there aren’t set time limits for when consumer guarantees no longer apply to different products. There also aren’t any penalties for unfairly refusing to provide a remedy to a customer when they are entitled to one under Australian Consumer Law.
Under the ACL, you can seek a remedy for a faulty product within a reasonable period after the date of purchase or delivery
“Businesses are taking advantage of the uncertainty that is partly of their own creation through poor after-sales service, because they can basically get away with it,” Kelly says.
Even if a business is clear on its website about your consumer rights, customers may receive pushback from sales staff, who may be trained to sell extended warranties or receive a commission for doing so.
Beware staff upselling you an extended warranty or downplaying your existing consumer rights.
Government reforms promise tougher penalties
The federal government plans to introduce penalties for businesses failing to provide a remedy when customers are entitled to one, though it is unclear when these reforms will be implemented.
The ACCC has also advocated for requirements that manufacturers publish guidance on how long each of their products should reasonably last, which may not be included in upcoming reforms.
While Australians wait for the government to implement stronger protections, here are a few things to consider when trying to understand how long your product will be covered by ACL when trying to seek a remedy.
How long you can reasonably expect a product to last is not straightforward, but several retailers admit that your right to a remedy under the ACL may be available even after the extended warranty period has expired.
Several retailers admit that your right to a remedy under the ACL may be available even after the extended warranty period has expired
Keep in mind it may not be reasonable to seek a remedy under the ACL towards the end of a product’s life, and you probably cannot expect a $400 dishwasher to last as long as a $2000 one.
The ACCC and state and territory regulators have also produced a guide on product durability and for how long a product should be of an acceptable quality.
Ultimately, the risk that businesses might refuse to provide customers with the rights they are entitled to should not be a reason to purchase an extended warranty.
The claim: Several retailers’ extended warranties provide assurances like “specified days for repair time guarantee”, which they claim aren’t available under the Australian Consumer Law.
The reality: While the ACL doesn’t provide an exact timeframe for how quickly a business must repair a product, it does state that they must be repaired within a reasonable time, or the customer is to be given a refund or replacement.
In the case of a major problem with a product, a customer can generally seek a repair or refund anyway, and does not need to accept a repair.
‘Benefit’ #3: ‘Experienced staff’ manage the claim process and can provide technical advice
The claim: Another unique benefit that retailers claim their extended warranties provide is “the convenience of having experienced operational staff to manage the repair and/or replacement process” and access to “Tool-free technical assistance”.
An Officeworks spokesperson tells us these “benefits” refer to a dedicated claims team and hotline operated by a third-party business that manages the extended warranty process. Some other major retailers also outsource their extended warranty services to external companies.
The reality: This is a service that customers do not need to pay for. If you are seeking a repair, refund or replacement under the ACL, the retailers themselves must help you with this process.
Officeworks tells us customers are entitled to help from their staff for seeking a remedy under the ACL regardless of whether they’ve bought an extended warranty.
Officeworks also says the “Toll Free” service available in its extended warranty is for “more technical or harder-to-diagnose issues”, like problems with computer and printer hardware.
While it is true this is not a right available under Australian Consumer Law, manufacturers and software companies often provide support to customers free of charge anyway.
The claim: Several retailers including Harvey Norman and The Good Guys include with their extended warranties a series of special offers and discounts on products and services at their stores.
The reality: Exclusive offers can provide legitimate value, but you should weigh up whether these extras will be beneficial to you, given the price of extended warranties can be quite steep.
Retailers facing class action over extended warranties
CHOICE has warned consumers about extended warranties for years, but now they’re under the spotlight in the courts too.
In October 2026, a class action was launched against JB Hi-Fi in the Supreme Court of Victoria for allegedly misleading consumers by claiming extended warranties offered longer coverage and additional benefits than what’s guaranteed under the ACL. The class action estimates more than eight million customers are affected.
A separate class action has been launched against Harvey Normal for allegedly offering an extended warranty that offered little to no additional value to customers.
James is a journalist with CHOICE's editorial and investigations team, decoding complicated consumer issues and reporting on how corporations and businesses affect the lives of Australians.
He has previously created podcast series for We Are Explorers and Protect Our Winters Australia, and has published in Cosmos and The Citizen. James has a particular interest reporting on science, environmental and social issues, and was a recipient of a JEERA Ossie Award for his journalism.
James has a Master of Journalism and Bachelor of Science in Physiology from the University of Melbourne. LinkedIn
James is a journalist with CHOICE's editorial and investigations team, decoding complicated consumer issues and reporting on how corporations and businesses affect the lives of Australians.
He has previously created podcast series for We Are Explorers and Protect Our Winters Australia, and has published in Cosmos and The Citizen. James has a particular interest reporting on science, environmental and social issues, and was a recipient of a JEERA Ossie Award for his journalism.
James has a Master of Journalism and Bachelor of Science in Physiology from the University of Melbourne. LinkedIn
For more than 60 years, CHOICE has been fighting the good fight for Australian consumers.
In the past year alone we've uncovered systemic issues with sunscreens, investigated shonky supermarket pricing, fought for stronger scam protections and helped make complex energy pricing fairer and clearer.
CHOICE is here to provide unbiased advice and independent testing in our world-class labs. We buy the products we test, just like you do, and our expert reviews are influence free. We’re here to help you choose smarter. Hopefully you’ll also save some money along the way.
Thanks to CHOICE, you’ll never be alone when a business treats you unfairly. You can support our work by joining or donating to our cause.