Skip to content   Skip to footer navigation 

Car insurance comparison

Buy smarter with CHOICE membership

Join CHOICE

Or Learn more

Last updated: 04 September 2025
Fact-checked

Fact-checked

Checked for accuracy by our qualified verifiers and subject experts. Find out more about fact-checking at CHOICE.

Compare over 50 car insurers to find the best cover for your ride. Select cover that has your choice of repairer, rental car after an accident, or no excess cover for windscreen replacements from the biggest brands on the market – Allianz, Aldi, Australian Seniors, COTA, APIA, Everyday, NRMA, RACV, Coles, GIO, Youi and more.

Unlike other insurance comparison websites, we don't get paid by any of the insurers we're comparing. This means you sometimes won't see price scores for insurers like NRMA and RACV, but it also means we don't recommend insurers based on how much they pay comparison websites. We only recommend the best insurance policies for you.

Read more

Do you need car insurance?

If your car is roadworthy and registered, then you already have compulsory third party (CTP) car insurance. This covers the cost of compensation claims if anyone driving your car injures someone else in an accident. But CTP insurance doesn't cover damage to your own, or someone else's car. So unless you want to fork out to repair someone else's Porsche, or be left without a car if yours is written off in an accident, then taking out insurance on top of that is a good idea.

What car insurance do you need?

  • Compulsory third party (CTP): Covers compensation to people injured in an accident you caused. No cover for your own or other people’s property and cars.
  • Third party property: Covers other people's cars and property damage.
  • Third party fire and theft: Covers other people's cars and property damage. Cover for your car for theft or fire damage.
  • Comprehensive: Covers other people's cars and property damage. Cover for your car for theft, fire, natural disasters, vandalism and accidents, even if you're at fault.

How much is car insurance?

The cost of comprehensive car insurance depends on factors such as your driving record, your vehicle and where you live. The policy with the cheapest average premium is $795 in Tasmania, while the policy with the most expensive average premium is $3,065 in Victoria.

How to save money on car insurance?

Shopping around is the most effective way to save on car insurance. Not only do premiums vary widely between insurers, they also vary between new and old customers. We call it the loyalty penalty: the insurers cash in on consumers who renew their policies without shopping around. So even if you have stayed with your insurers for years and years and are promised high loyalty discounts, you should shop around when your insurance is up for renewal to see if there are any better deals out there. In all states, average premiums for the most expensive policy are more than double the average premiums for the cheapest, so there are a lot of savings to be found.

Show less

Brand

Expand to view more details.

List of brands we tested in this review.

    enter value/s in increments of 1 between 0 and 0

    Recommended products

    Remove product

    Member only

    This test score is for members only. Join now to unlock our expert results.

    Already a member?

    Price score

    Expand to view more details.

    The higher the percentage score, the cheaper the policy compared to other products. This score is across all policies Australia wide, but premiums can differ a lot depending on where you live. Check the $ price rating for your region or state in our comparison table to find a closer price indication for your home. "N/A" means the insurer doesn't operate here, or doesn't participate in the premium sharing program we use to collect pricing data.

    enter value/s in increments of i between 28 and 85

    Available in ACT

      Available in NSW

        Available in NT

          Available in Queensland

            Available in SA

              Available in Tasmania

                Available in Victoria

                  Available in WA

                    Included in this comparison

                    Members-only access
                    • Cover score
                    • Price score
                    • Provider
                    • Cooling off period
                    • Claims satisfaction
                    • Pay-by-the-month charge
                    • ACT price comparison
                    • NSW price comparison
                    • NT price comparison
                    • Queensland price comparison
                    • SA price comparison
                    • Tasmania price comparison
                    • Victoria price comparison
                    • WA price comparison
                    • How your car is valued
                    • Insured events
                    • Emergency repairs
                    • Out-of-hours claiming
                    • Choice of repairer
                    • Replacement parts used in repairs
                    • Additional excesses
                    • Legal liability cover
                    • Personal property cover
                    • Child seat cover
                    • Keys cover
                    • Trailer cover
                    • Accommodation and transport when far from home
                    • Transport costs
                    • Towing after an incident
                    • New car replacement
                    • Reduced excess on glass claims
                    • Roadside assistance
                    • Rental car after theft
                    • Rental car after not-at-fault incident
                    • Rental car after any incident
                    • Card_New car replacement
                    • Card_How your car is valued
                    • Card_Repairs

                    Results

                    Your filters

                    Clear all filters

                    Product selected for a detailed comparison

                    Clear all

                    Get full access to all our tests and reviews

                    or Log in