CHOICE reveals the best and worst dishwasher detergents

One Earth Choice detergent receives a top score, while another ranks among the worst.

Consumer group CHOICE has tested 34 dishwasher detergents to reveal which ones will leave your dishes sparkling clean – and which might leave you wondering whether you remembered to add detergent at all. 

“Finish Powerball Ultimate 0% Tabs took first place, receiving a score of 77%. Close behind were Finish Powerball Ultimate Plus Tabs and Earth Choice All-in-1 Dish Tablets, both scoring 76%,” says CHOICE household expert, Chris Barnes. 

“All three detergents performed well at removing stubborn stains throughout the dishwasher cycle. However, if you’re looking for a budget-friendly option, Earth Choice All-in-1 detergent is significantly cheaper, costing just 42 cents per wash compared with more than $1 per wash for the Finish products,” says Barnes. 

“Unfortunately, not all detergents delivered sparkling results. Housebrite Dishwasher Powder was the lowest performing detergent, scoring 40% in the latest testing. Earth Choice Dishwasher Powder Lemon Fresh also disappointed, scoring 47%,” says Barnes.

“The results show that you should never assume all products from the same brand will perform equally well. Choosing the right detergent can make a big difference to your dishwasher results, saving you time and money,” says Barnes. 

The best performing dishwasher detergents: 

1. Finish Powerball Ultimate 0% Tabs

CHOICE Expert Rating: 77%

Cost per wash: $1.07

2. Earth Choice All-in-1 Dish Tablets 

CHOICE Expert Rating: 76% 

Cost per wash: $0.42

2. Finish Powerball Ultimate Plus Tabs

CHOICE Expert Rating: 76%

Cost per wash: $1.26

The worst performing dishwasher detergents:

1. Housebrite Brite Dishwasher Powder

CHOICE Expert Rating: 40%

Cost per wash: $0.08

2. Earth Choice Dishwasher Powder Lemon Fresh

CHOICE Expert Rating: 47%

Cost per wash: $0.21


Erin Barton is the Media advisor at CHOICE. Erin supports the CHOICE media strategy by placing our stories with external outlets to reach the general public. She communicates our work through the media, and promotes the value of CHOICE to make an impact on the Australian community. Erin has a Bachelor of Communication from the University of Technology Sydney.

Erin Barton is the Media advisor at CHOICE. Erin supports the CHOICE media strategy by placing our stories with external outlets to reach the general public. She communicates our work through the media, and promotes the value of CHOICE to make an impact on the Australian community. Erin has a Bachelor of Communication from the University of Technology Sydney.