Bike lights review

Visibility is vital when riding a bike at night, but which bike lights are the best?
 
Get access to all CHOICE BENEFITS
$1.91/wk
*Billed quarterly
 
 
 
  • Updated:1 May 2012
  • Author:Rebecca Gatto
  • rateraterateraterate: Member rating
 

01 .Introduction

Bikelight_lead_APR2012_WEB

Over 60 bike lights, priced from $15 to $1699, have been reviewed by a panel of industry experts from the cycling community.

This review reveals which bike lights:

  • Are the most visible
  • Are the most durable
  • Are the easiest to use, fit and remove.

On this page:

As road users, bike riders are legally obliged to be visible when riding in the dark, so it’s important that the lights you fit to your bike make you as visible as possible.

Lights are now being designed for convenience with many available that are USB rechargeable and can be mounted with easy-to-use silicone straps. However make sure your lights are tightly secured – if not you could go over a bump or pot hole and your lights can end up pointing at the ground.

What's the law?

When you ride your bicycle at night or in low-visibility conditions, such as fog or heavy rain, the Australian Road Rules (which form the basis of state and territory road rules) requires that you have lights. These include:

  • A white light at the front.
  • A red light at rear.
  • A rear red reflector

The lights can be steady or flashing, and must be visible for at least 200 metres. Ideally, they should also be visible 50 metres from the side. The red rear reflector should be visible from 50 meters from the rear when light is projected onto it by a vehicle's headlight at low beam. Good head-on and angled visbility is essential - but durability, size, ease of fitting and removing, and battery replacement is also important to consider when buying a bike light. 

Bicycle Victoria

Bicycle Victoria takes the issue of visibility seriously and each year gathers a panel of industry experts, including CHOICE, to assess a range of bike lights. The panel gathers in an inner-city Melbourne laneway after sunset and assesses each light in line with the Australian Road Rules.

Ride On, the Bicycle Victoria magazine, recently put the newest batch of lights to the test, a combination of front and rear compact lights and high-powered LED's were tested. See the full report report in their April/May issue.

Find out more about bikes and bike accessories

Brands and models tested

Compact front lights
  • BBB High Integrate
  • BBB Spark #
  • Blackburn Flea 2.0 USB #
  • Blackburn Voyager bracket-less
  • Cateye Hybrid
  • Exposure Lights Flash bracket-less
  • Illumenox Highpower SS-L1222W
  • Illumenox Vega 1W #
  • Knog Blinder #
  • Knog Boomer USB #
  • Knog Gekko Bracket-less
  • Moon Mask #
  • Planet Bike Beamer 5 #
  • Planet Bike Blaze 2W
  • Portland Design Works Dreadnought #
  • Portland Design Works Spaceship
  • Serfas Raider USL-5 #
  • Smart 1W
  • Tioga ET #
  • X-tech #
Compact rear lights
  • BBB BLS-Highlaser bracket-less
  • BBB Spark #
  • Cateye Rapid 5 #
  • Cygo-Lite Hotshot USB #
  • Exposure Lights Flare bracket-less
  • Fibre Flare Long Red bracket-less
  • Illumenox Crocolight
  • Infini Amuse Rear bracket-less
  • Knog Beetle bracket-less
  • Knog Blinder #
  • Knog Boomer USB #
  • Moon Gem 3.0 #
  • Moon Shield #
  • Nite Rider Cherry Bomb 1W #
  • Niteflux Red Zone 4 bracket-less
  • Planet Bike Blinky Superflash
  • Portland Design Works Radbot 1000 #
  • Reelight SL620 power back up
  • Serfas Raider rear USL-5R #
  • Serfas TL-ST Seat Stay Taillight #
  • Skully 1W Rear bracket-less
  • Smart Two Eyes
  • S-Sun Eaglefly
  • Tioga Dual Eyes
  • Tioga ET #
Dynamo front lights
  • Busch and Muller IQ-Cyo
  • Busch and Muller IQ-Fly
  • Busch and Muller Oval Senso Plus
  • Gazelle Mendeo Plus Fenderlight
  • Reelight SL620 power back up
  • Schmidt Edelux
  • Supernova E3 Por Glare-free
Dynamo rear lights
  • Busch and Muller Seculite Plus
  • Busch and Muller D-Toplight XS plus
  • Supernova E3 tail seat-post mount
High-powered front lights
  • Ay-Up V Twin Sport #
  • BBB Highpower
  • Cygo-Lite Expilion 350 #
  • Cygo-Lite Expolion 170 #
  • Exposure Lights Diablo cable-free
  • Exposure Lights Joystick cable-free
  • Literover Supernova #
  • Literover Trail Blazer
  • Moon Power 500 #
  • NiteRider Mi.Newt Pro 750 #
  • Serfas TL500 #
High-powered rear lights
  • Ay-Up Twin Sport with red caps
  • Literover Tail Gator

# Newly tested models.

How we test

The annual bike lights test brings together a panel of industry experts from the cycling community to act as judges. The lights are assessed at night on a suburban road with a popular cycle path, at a distance of 200m, and also at 50m with the lights angled at 45° (to simulate the bike approaching an intersection). The flash rate, where applicable, was also assessed.

Durability, size, ease of fitting and removing, waterproofness and battery replacement should also be considered when buying a light. So Bicycle Victoria teams up with RMIT industrial design students who assess these categories and give a rating out of 10 for each light.

Visibility ratings (out of 100) and industrial design ratings (out of 10) are combined to determine the overall score. Visibility is given the highest weighting (60%). 

What's new?

This year a couple of extra tests were included. Ride On joined forces with RMIT to use their lux meter, a device that measures brightness. Conducted in a controlled environment, each light was measured from 10m, following the stringent German StVZO standard for bicycle lighting.

Interestingly, the panel’s judgement of the most visible lights didn’t gel with the lux meter results. According to the lux meter, the brightest front compact light was rated eighth by the panel out of the 11 front lights. The most visible light according to the judges was 5.8 lux. People take into account a range of environmental factors when determining brightness, which may account for these differences.

Ride On has found that people are interested in how easily lights can turn on accidentally, so RMIT was asked to include this when assessing their design and construction. The rating for this was incorporated into the useability score.

There were three significant casualties during the durability test, which drops the lights from handlebar height. The Moon Gem 3.0 broke apart, the housing of the central LED of the Serfas TL-ST Seat Stay Taillight broke and the connection between the light and battery became loose on the Ilumenox Vega. 

 
 

 

6 CHOICE buys

Tioga Dual Eyes

Scored 78/100 | $3578%
 

Moon Mask

Scored 77/100 | $6077%
 

Moon Power 500

Scored 77/100 | $15077%
 

Literover Trail Blazer

Scored 76/100 | $9976%
 

Gazelle Medeo Plus Fenderlight

Scored 72/100 | $169972%
 

Ilumenox Highpower SS L1222W

Scored 71/100 | $7971%
 
 

Instructions

Comparison table list

  • By default ALL tested products are listed. You can select up to five items to view in a side by side comparison.
  • Additional columns can be viewed by using the Next/Previous buttons.

Using the filters

  • Use the filters to show only products that meet your specific requirements or which have the specific features you're interested in. Selecting filters automatically updates the Comparison table list.
  • The number shown in brackets represents the number of products that will be shown if you select that filter.
  • You can view additional filters by selecting the Show more filters button.

Compare products

 
Table Allowing the user to select a number of products dependant on their filter options.
Items to compare

Select up to 5 items below.
Then click the compare button

 
Price ($)Overall scoreTypeVisibility (%)Useability (out of 10)Durability (out of 10)Waterproofness (out of 10)Value for money (out of 10)Standlight (minutes)Burn time (hours)Weight (grams)BatteriesContactBrand
               
Mask #6077Compact front light869.2588.58Moon
Raider USL-5 #6074Compact front light809109.57.5Serfas
Highpower SS-L1222W7971Compact front light7978107Ilumenox
Blinder #5071Compact front light759.25998Knog
Beamer 5 #3970Compact front light756.758108Planet bike
Dreadnought #5968Compact front light814.588.57Portland Design Works
Flea 2.0 USB #6567Compact front light709.251097Blackburn
ET #2565Compact front light688108.57.5Tioga
Spark #4565Compact front light668.75109.57BBB
Gekko bracket-less5064Compact front light638.338108Knog
Boomer USB #5062Compact front light658.751077Knog
Blaze 2W9059Compact front light687.67764Planet bike
1W8058Compact front light617.67294Smart
Hybrid6056Compact front light526.679108Cateye
Vega 1W #15054Compact front light678.75623Illumenox
High Integrate6552Compact front light627753BBB
Spaceship3550Compact front light584.67864Portland Design Works
#2050Compact front light648713X-tech
Flash bracket-less7949Compact front light456.678105Exposure lights
Voyager bracket-less2039Compact front light465934Blackburn
Dual Eyes3578Compact rear light858.338109Tioga
Eaglefly2577Compact rear light887.334107S-Sun
BLS-Highlaser bracket-less3576Compact rear light847.334108BBB
Sheild #6073Compact rear light837.51097Moon
Red Zone 4 bracket-less9972Compact rear light7988107Niteflux
1W Rear bracket-less2570Compact rear light816996Skully
Blinder #5070Compact rear light729.25998Knog
Raider rear USL-5R #6067Compact rear light699109.57Serfas
Spark #4566Compact rear light708.751087BBB
Two Eyes4563Compact rear light687.33896Smart
Blinky Superflash3563Compact rear light6578107Planet bike
Crocolight2962Compact rear light6758107Ilumenox
Rapid 5 #5060Compact rear light561099.57Cateye
Gem 3.0 #3560Compact rear light668.25775Moon
Beetle bracket-less3559Compact rear light66510104Knog
Long Red bracket-less3559Compact rear light6081096Fibre flare
Hotshot USB #7057Compact rear light588.597.56Cygo-Lite
Cherry Bomb 1W #4056Compact rear light695.2594.55Nite Rider
Amuse Rear bracket-less1555Compact rear light6761063Infini
Flare bracket-less7949Compact rear light5358102Exposure Lights
ET #2545Compact rear light406.751095Tioga
Radbot 1000 #5945Compact rear light547.75923Portland Design Works
SL620 power back up2042Compact rear light525842Reelight
Boomer USB #5039Compact rear light3861055Knog
TL-ST Seat Stay Taillight #3034Compact rear light2910102.54Serfas
Medeo Plus Fenderlight169972Dynamo front56109910Gazelle
E3 Pro Glare-free35066Dynamo front5588107Supernova
Edelux29966Dynamo front5388108Schmidt
IQ-Fly14965Dynamo front538799Busch and Muller
IQ-Cyo22959Dynamo front578845Busch and Muller
Oval Senso Plus10957Dynamo front496687Busch and Muller
SL620 power back up7742Dynamo front2866103Reelight
E3 tail seat-post mount13063Dynamo rear5088107Supernova
Seculite Plus6554Dynamo rear4655106Busch and Muller
D-Toplight XS plus6942Dynamo rear415444Busch and Muller
Power 500 #15077High-powered front819.881099Moon
Trail Blazer9976High-powered front846.57109Literover
Supernova #15072High-powered front78810107Lightrover
TL 500 #16070High-powered front798.25787Serfas
Mi.Newt Pro 750 #32969High-powered front7969106NiteRider
Expilion 170 #13962High-powered front62810107Cygo-Lite
V Twin Sport #27561High-powered front686.51095Ay-Up
Highpower28057High-powered front635.58104BBB
Expilion 350 #19957High-powered front57810105Cygo-Lite
Joystick cable-free32056High-powered front618983Exposure Lights
Diablo cable-free45055High-powered front627.5982Exposure Lights
Twin Sport with red caps26468High-powered rear7179108Ay-Up
Tail Gator9962High-powered rear6947107Literover
 
              
 

Using the table

# Newly tested models.
Overall score is made up of: Visibility - 60%, Useability (out of 10), Durability (out of 10), Waterproofness (out of 10) and Value for money (out of 10).
Standlight only applies to dynamo lights and refers to how long the light will stay on after you stop pedalling.
Burn time only applies to high-powered LEDs and refers to how long the lights will run for after charging.

Staying visible

  • Check your lights regularly; if they're looking dim, it's time to replace the batteries.
  • It's worth carrying a backup light or two on your bike or backpack - lights can fail unexpectedly, especially in the rain.
  • Wear light-coloured or reflective clothing, or a reflective strip or vest.
  • Steady lights are good for a rider's visability. However, flashing lights are more distinctive and allow other road users to see you better.
  • Most bike lights use LEDs rather than globes. Lights with multiple LEDs are usually brightest but a single LED can still be very bright if the light has a good reflector.
  • Ask the bike shop if you can test the lights before buying. Try the different flash rates – if the flash is too slow you'll travel further between each flash giving motorists an inaccurate judgement of your location. If it's too fast, it'll create a strobe effect, again distorting motorist's judgement of your exact location. 
  • Check the light is clearly visible when side-on or at an angle.
  • Light mounting brackets will fit most bikes but check they'll fit yours.
  • Ideally the light should use easily obtainable batteries such as AAs or AAAs.
  • Riders are easiest to see when their lights are mounted at handlebar height.
  • Helmet-mounted lights aren't ideal - they can overwhelm other riders.
  • Bear in mind that high-powered lights that are too bright can blind other riders and road users. Mounting them at the correct height should help to avoid this.

Dynamo vs high-powered LED

Since 2010, dynamo lights and high-powered LEDs have been included alongside compact lights in the annual test.

Dynamos don’t require batteries – they’re powered by rubbing on the wheel or hub. Hub dynamos are built into the front wheel of the bike, which requires a wheel rebuild that can be a pricey exercise costing anywhere from $500. However, they’re silent, have little drag and are efficient. Cheaper options are bottle dynamos, which have more drag, are noisy and wear the tyres due to contact with the sidewall of the tyre. Magnetic induction dynamos may have no drag, noise or wear, but they’re heavy and don’t provide the same level of light as hub dynamos.

High-powered LEDs are great for being seen and are most useful if they come with a strobe function – without one their light can meld with the surrounding street and traffic lights. Some require a separate battery pack that is strapped to the bike, while others are “cable free” where the battery is incorporated into the light. For most batteries, simply plug the battery into the mains power with either a charger or USB to charge these lights. It can take two to five hours to fully charge them, and the light can run out in only a few hours, so look for one with a high burn time. If your light uses batteries (eg AAA), always carry spares so you never end up stranded.  

How to comment

Here's your chance to join in the debate. Just click in the comment box and let the CHOICE Community know what you think, or view all of the comments on this article.

Reporting offensive comments

If you see something offensive or something that just shouldn't be there, hit the report button and let us know immediately. View the Terms of use for user comments.

 

Make a Comment