This report is for members and single purchase only.
Already a member? Sign in here

Not a member?

To access this expert review, join now for only $7.98 / month
(billed quarterly as $23.95 on a recurring basis until you cancel).

Member-only content

MP3 and MP4 player reviews

We compare two popular smartphones with the latest in media players.
To access this report, which includes CHOICE 'Best Buy' and an interactive comparison table, become a member now.
JOIN CHOICE or buy this single report: $23
Learn more


Portable media player with earbuds and catalogues

We review 21 MP3 and MP4 players priced from $50 to $799, including two smartphones.

Through our rigorous testing we reveal which media players:

  • Are the easiest to use
  • Have the best sound and video quality
  • Have the longest battery lives
  • Are the most durable.

On this page you'll find:

For more information about Portable media players, see Phones and Mobile devices.

Video: How we test media players

An insight into how CHOICE tests media players.

Digital music or MP3/MP4 players have evolved over the last decade to the point where the latest models provide an intuitive interface and a simple, effective way to get music from a computer into your pocket.

Most of the models tested are flash memory devices, using either removable cards or internal storage, supporting memory sizes from 4GB to 32GB.

Apple still dominates this market, with the Nano and Touch devices still available. While the Nano is quite basic, the Touch offers multiple functionality via apps. Following requests from some members, we’ve included some devices that only play audio in this test, and at the other end of the spectrum, we’ve also looked at two popular smartphones, the iPhone 4S and Samsung Galaxy III, to see how they compare with dedicated MP3/4 players.

For a device that in many cases does only one or two things, you shouldn’t expect to pay more than $300 for a decent MP3 player, and much less for a no-frills player.The smartphones included will cost a good deal more - but they pack more features in.

Models tested

Apple iPhone 4S
Apple iPod Nano
Apple iPod Touch
Archos 24b Vision (A)
Coby MP800-4G (A)
Cowon iAudio 10
Cowon X7
Cowon X9
Cowon Z2 Plenue
Creative Zen X-Fi 3
Philips GoGear Ariaz MP4 Player
Philips GoGear Connect 3 (A)
Philips GoGear Raga
Philips GoGear SoundDot (A)
Philips GoGear Vibe
Samsung Galaxy Player 3.6 (A)
Samsung Galaxy Player 4.2 YP-G1C (A)
Samsung Galaxy S III
Sony NWZ-E475
Sony NWZ-F806 (A)
Sony NWZ-Z1050

(A) These players are not directly distributed within Australia, but can be ordered online.

How we test

Ease of use Our testers check instructions, how easy the players are to set up, play music and video and rip and transfer music and video files with the software provided or, if none is supplied, using Windows Media Player (or iTunes with Apple products). They also evaluate how easy each player is to navigate and its basic functions and how much sound leakage there is from the devices.

Sound quality Our technical experts listen to each player through both the supplied headphones and a high quality pair of headphones. They listen to a variety of types of music.

Video quality They watch the video and assess it for colour, clarity and accuracy of rendition, as well as assess display size, compatibility with video formats and battery life under video.

Battery life The media players have files loaded and are played until they no longer function - this is done for audio files. They are also tested for charging time.

Durability We put the media players through a tumble test, letting each model rotate over 80cm for a minute, or around 20 falls. We also subject both the face and body to a scratch test.

Want more?
Get access to our independent testing reports and save yourself time and money.
Purchase the MP3 and MP4 player reviews report
Subscribe to Choice


Sign up to our free

Receive FREE email updates of our latest tests, consumer news and CHOICE marketing promotions.

Your say - Choice voice

Make a Comment

Members – Sign in on the top right to contribute to comments