Dishwasher detergent reviews

Tablets are convenient but cost more than double per wash than powders.
 
Get access to all CHOICE BENEFITS
$1.91/wk
*Billed quarterly
 
 
 
  • Updated:2 Jun 2009
 

02.Results

The following models scored the best results in our test.
What to buy
Brand Cost per wash
Tablets
Finish Powerball All-in-1 10 Power Actions Tablets $0.53
Finish Powerball Max-in-1 Power Tabs $0.58
Best BuyLogix Automatic Dishwashing Tablets (ALDI)   $0.16
Powders
Morning Fresh Complete Dishwashing Powder Lemon Fresh $0.18
Logix Automatic Dishwashing Powder (ALDI) $0.15
Best BuyColes Smart Buy Automatic Dishwasher Powder   $0.07
Green options
Ecover Ecological Automatic Dishwasher Tablets $0.72
Best BuyEcostore Auto Dishwash Powder Concentrate   $0.18
Squeek Phosphate-free Concentrate Auto Dishwash Sachets $0.26
Best BuySeventh Generation Automatic Dishwashing Detergent   $0.19

Green options are good performers that claim a low environment hazard – chlorine- and phosphate-free, totally biodegradable (not just the surfactant), the packaging is 100% recyclable, minimal petroleum-derived ingredients and no dyes or artificial fragrances.

If you’d like to know more about what to look for when buying green products, The Australian Green Consumer Guide is a good reference and is available from CHOICE Books.

 

 

Results table

Full results for all models are shown in the table below.

Brand / product (in rank order; followed by number of trialists
TypeOverall score (%)Cleaning score (%)Streak-free score (%)Dissolvable wrappersContains rinse aidActive oxygen (no chlorine bleach)No phosphatesEnzymesChild safe capCost per wash (cents)*
Finish PowerBall All-in-1 10 Power Actions Tablets (52)
Tablet 89 90 87 53
Finish PowerBall Max-in-1 Power Tabs (42)
Tablet 85 85 85 58
Logix Automatic Dishwashing Powder (ALDI) (40)
Powder 83 83 81 na 15
Morning Fresh Complete Dishwashing Powder Lemon Fresh (40)
Powder 83 83 82 na 18
Coles Smart Buy Automatic Dishwasher Powder (49)
Powder 81 82 79 na 7
Ecover Ecological Automatic Dishwasher Tablets (47) (A)
Tablet 81 81 80 72
Ecostore Auto Dishwash Powder Concentrate (38)
Powder 80 80 79 na ns 18
Home Brand 3 in 1 Dishwasher Tablets (Woolworths) (37)
Tablet 80 80 81 19
Logix Automatic Dishwashing Tablets (ALDI) (43)
Tablet 80 80 80 16
Morning Fresh Complete with Hydrofilm Wrapper (47)
Tablet 80 80 79 37
Squeek Phosphate Free Concentrate Auto Dishwash Sachets (41) (A)
Powder 79 79 80 na 26
Swift Boosted 4 in 1 Action Auto Dishwash Tablets (IGA) (52)
Tablet 79 79 79 28
Woolworths Select Dishwasher Tablets 8 in 1 Action (45)
Tablet 79 80 76 50
You’ll Love Coles Ultra Action Dishwasher Tablets 5 in 1 (49)
Tablet 79 79 79 36
Seventh Generation Automatic Dishwashing Detergent (37) (A)
Powder 78 79 74 na 19
Kwit Double Action Lemon Dishwasher Powder (42)
Powder 77 77 75 na 18
Tundra Automatic Dishwashing Powder (ALDI) (36)
Powder 77 77 75 na 7
Finish Power Powder (49)
Powder 76 76 74 na ns 19
Black & Gold Automatic Dishwashing Detergent Powder Lemon (IGA) (42)
Powder 68 68 68 na 8

Using the table

* Cost per wash is per tablet or per 30g of powder based on what we paid in February 2009.
(A) “Eco-friendly” products.
na Not applicable.
ns Not stated.

Behind the hype

Marketing claims on the packaging fall just short of being able to unload your dishwasher for you. In this trial we’ve come across claims such as Max-in-1 (with 11 actions), All-in-1 10 power actions, 8-in-1, 5-in-1, and 4-in-1. These claims refer to the number of performance actions or ingredients included in the product, such as enzymes to break down food scraps. But in most cases it’s simply stating the inclusion of any or all typical dishwasher detergent ingredients. It doesn’t always mean you get anything extra compared with another detergent that isn’t making any x-in-one claim. For example, almost all detergents on trial have enzymes, but not all list explicit claims.

 

How to comment

Here's your chance to join in the debate. Just click in the comment box and let the CHOICE Community know what you think, or view all of the comments on this article.

Reporting offensive comments

If you see something offensive or something that just shouldn't be there, hit the report button and let us know immediately. View the Terms of use for user comments.

 

Make a Comment