Skip to content   Skip to footer navigation 
What's behind
the score?
Watch the video
Last updated: 15 September 2018

For a healthy-looking lawn, a mulcher mower that returns the cut clippings back into the lawn could be the right choice for you. But a catcher mower can also be a good option as you can use the clippings as compost. See our buying guide for what to look for in a new lawnmower, and how we test explains our testing rigour.

Read more

We put petrol-powered mulcher and catcher-only lawnmowers to the test.

Our expert review will show you:

  • which models perform best in mulching and catcher modes
  • which ones are easiest to use
  • which models have the features and specifications to suit your needs.

Got a smaller yard, or don't like messing about with petrol? See our battery (cordless) and electric lawnmower reviews.

Show less

Narrow your results

Your filters

Clear all filters


Expand to view more details.

List of brands we tested in this review.


    Expand to view more details.

    Recommended or average retail.

    enter value/s in increments of 1 between 269 and 1795

    Top filters

    Remove product

    Member only

    This test score is for members only. Join now to unlock our expert results.

    Join now

    Already a member?

    Drive type

    Expand to view more details.

    Push – The lawnmower is pushed manually.

    Self-propelled – The motor also drives the wheels to make pushing easier. Can be useful for large lawns or hilly areas. These models usually have just a single speed but some have a gear lever allowing you to select between two or three speeds.

      Key start

      Expand to view more details.

      Key start models are started with a  key, toggle or button rather than a pull cord.

        Cut type

        Expand to view more details.

        Catcher/mulcher: can be used in both modes. Catcher: has no mulching option.

          Width of cut (cm)

          Expand to view more details.

          The width of the cutting blades; the wider the cut, the fewer passes needed to mow the lawn.

          enter value/s in increments of i between 42 and 76

          Test results

          Noise at users position (dB)

          Expand to view more details.

          Our testers measure the lawnmower's noise at the operator's ear level.

          enter value/s in increments of i between 79 and 90


          enter value/s in increments of i between 23 and 74

          Main body material

          Expand to view more details.

          Steel: durable but can be more prone to rusting. Alloy: can be more expensive but tends to be more rust-resistant and may be lighter. Plastic: much lighter, rust immune, but may not be as durable.

            Starter toggle location

            Expand to view more details.

            All petrol mowers are turned on via a pull cord; some are mounted on the handle, some are on motor and some have an electric ignition as well. Look for the key start filter to narrow down those that start via key.

              Cutting positions

              Expand to view more details.

              Number of cutting positions. A higher number offers greater versatility.

              enter value/s in increments of i between 5 and 13


              Wash nozzle

              Expand to view more details.

              Lets you clean the underside of the mower more easily, without turning it on its side.

                Rear deflector

                Expand to view more details.

                Deflects clippings and debris to one side so they don't fly straight back at the user. Useful if you want to want to mow without mulching and without the catcher.

                  Snorkel for air filter

                  Expand to view more details.

                  Air is drawn into the motor at a distance via a snorkel tube, rather than directly at motor level. This reduces the amount of dust getting into the air filter and motor, so the filter won't need to be cleaned or replaced as often and the motor should last longer.

                    Fuel tap

                      Extra chute

                      Expand to view more details.

                      Whether the mower comes standard with an extra chute attachment, typically a side chute.

                        Related products


                          Included in this review

                          Members-only access
                          • Overall score
                          • CHOICE buy
                          • Ease of use score
                          • Cutting score with catcher
                          • Cutting score mulching
                          • Vibration score
                          • Pushing score
                          • Handle score
                          • Controls score
                          • Height adjustment score
                          • Starter score
                          • Catcher score
                          • Noise at 7.5 metres (dB)
                          • Noise at users position (dB)
                          • Lowest cutting height (mm)
                          • Highest cutting height (mm)
                          • Closeness of cut to a vertical edge (mm)
                          • Good points
                          • Bad points
                          • Price
                          • Brand
                          • Model
                          • Status
                          • Drive type
                          • Cut type
                          • Main body material
                          • Starter toggle location
                          • Motor
                          • Cutting positions
                          • Width of cut (cm)
                          • Wash nozzle
                          • Quick release handle
                          • Blade control lever
                          • Rear deflector
                          • Key start
                          • Self start
                          • Snorkel for air filter
                          • Chipper
                          • Extra chute
                          • Tilt adjustable deck
                          • Fuel tap
                          • Weight (kg)
                          • Warranty (yrs)
                          • Contact

                          Product selected for a detailed comparison

                          Clear all
                          Join 160 000 members using our independent test results to avoid costly mistakes. Get full access to all our tests and reviews.