Banana bread bake-off


Are celebrity packet mix banana breads better?

Banana bread on baking paper

Go bananas


You don't have to wait until Masterchef is back on the screen to have your celebrity chef fix in your home. Donna Hay and Adriano Zumbo both produce a range of supermarket packet baking mixes, offering a dusting of Masterchef magic to your brownies, cakes and muffins.

But do celebrity chef baking mixes give you a tastier treat? And how much are you paying for that celebrity endorsement?

In this article:

Celebrity chef banana breads vs the rest

We compared banana bread made in our kitchen lab from Donna Hay and Adriano Zumbo's packet mixes with banana bread from White Wings, Lighthouse and Coles brand packet mixes, as well as Coles' pre-baked banana bread. We also threw into the mix a homemade banana bread baked to our CHOICE home economist Fiona Mair's standard recipe

Fifty CHOICE staffers munched their way through all seven samples in a blind tasting then, in true Masterchef style, voted for their favourite. Our homemade banana bread was a convincing winner, receiving 42% of the votes, with Donna Hay's bread coming in a distant second (24% of the votes). Least popular was Adriano Zumbo's bread, which received just 4% of the votes.

For an accessible text-only version of this infographic, see the Product and % votes columns in the table below.

Celebrity mark-up

Donna Hay Wholesome Banana Bread
Donna Hay Wholesome Banana Bread
Adriano Zumbo Pash Me Banana Bread
Adriano Zumbo Pash Me Banana Bread

The price we paid for the packet mixes ranged from $2 (Coles) up to $7.70 (Donna Hay). And what you get for this is the dry ingredients, which in the Donna Hay product consists of brown sugar, flour (spelt and rice), raising agents, cinnamon and flavour. The combined dry ingredients in Fiona's recipe (brown sugar, wheat flour, bicarb and cinnamon) cost us a mere $0.73.

Once we added the cost of the additional ingredients required, like eggs, butter and bananas, we paid $4.86 for the Coles banana bread, while Donna Hay's set us back $14. Our homemade banana bread cost $6.05. 

Of course each recipe makes a different size loaf, so for a fair comparison, we've calculated the cost of each product per 100g. The Coles packet mix banana bread was still cheapest, at $0.52 per 100g. But the celebrity banana breads, at $1.01 per 100g (Adriano Zumbo) and $1.12 per 100g (Donna Hay), cost twice as much.  

With 24% of our tasters voting it as their favourite, some might consider Donna Hay's banana bread to be worth paying more for. A sachet of passionfruit curd (with which you can make passionfruit butter to spread on the bread) is included in the price of Zumbo’s making it trickier to compare. But with just 4% of the votes for the banana bread on its own, it certainly could benefit from some added passion.

At $0.62 per 100g, and with 42% of the votes, our homemade banana bread seems a pretty good option, if you're prepared to put in a little extra elbow grease.

Convenience

Fiona's banana bread may have been voted the tastiest, but admittedly the packet mixes have an (ever so slight) edge over her recipe for convenience. To make them you simply add a few extra ingredients (usually eggs, butter or oil, milk and mashed bananas), mix, and bake. Fiona's recipe requires you to cream the butter and sugar before mixing in the other ingredients and baking, which adds 1-2 minutes to the prep time. And of course you also have to measure out the flour, sugar, bicarb and cinnamon.

With no preparation or baking required, the Coles pre-baked product is obviously the most convenient of the lot (although just 8% of tasters voted it as their favourite).The White Wings product takes a few minutes less in the oven (40-50 mins) than the other banana breads (including Fiona’s) which take 55-60 mins to bake.

Our taste testers hard at work in the CHOICE kitchen lab

Supermarket banana bread fun facts

  • White Wings banana bread baking mix contains 9% dried banana and you're not required to add fresh banana to the mixture.
  • Zumbo's banana bread was the only product to contain nuts (1.5% walnuts). It also comes with a sachet of passionfruit curd with which you can make passionfruit butter (you need to add your own butter). We didn't use this in the tasting.
  • The Coles pre-made banana bread is frozen then 'thawed for your convenience', so it's not suitable for refreezing.
  • Donna Hay's banana bread mix lists sugar as its first ingredient. At almost 30% sugar (when prepared), it's more sugary than all the other supermarket banana breads we tested.
  • The Coles banana breads (both packet mix and pre-made) are the only products we tested that don't have added 'flavour' in the ingredients list.

Banana bread packet mix comparison

We tested seven banana breads, listed below in alphabetical order. To order by another criteria, simply click on the column headings.

Product Image % votes Pack
price
($)*
Cost of
extra
ingredients**
Total cost
(as prepared)
Total cost
per 100g
(as prepared)
Loaf weight
prepared
(g)***
Ingredients (in pack) Extra ingredients
(purchased separately)
Adriano Zumbo Pash Me Banana Bread (A) Adriano Zumbo Pash Me Banana Bread 4 7.00 2.87 9.87 1.01 972 Wheat flour, sugar, passionfruit curd (18%) [sugar, water, passionfruit pulp (14%), glucose syrup, thickener (1442), butter, egg powder, acidity regulator (330), salt, preservatives (202, 224), flavour, colours (160a, 171)], vegetable fats and oils [emulsifiers (471, 477), antioxidant (307)], walnuts (1.5), raising agents (450, sodium bicarbonate), molasses powder, salt, vegetable gum [xanthan], spice (cinnamon), maltodextrin, natural flavour. 2 eggs, 50g butter, 125mL milk, 2 bananas (200g)
Coles Banana Bread (pre-baked) Coles Banana Bread (pre-baked) 8 5.00 na 5.00 0.91 550 Wheat flour, banana (26%), sugar, egg, canola oil, salt, raising agents (500, 450), preservative (202). na
Coles Banana Bread Baking Mix Coles Banana Bread Baking Mix 8 2.00 2.86 4.86 0.52 936 Wheat flour, sugar, palm oil [emulsifiers (471, 477), antioxidant (307)], raising agents (450, 500), spices (cinnamon, nutmeg), salt, thickener (415), caramelised sugar. 2 eggs, 125mL oil, 125mL milk, 2 bananas (approx 250g)
Donna Hay Wholesome Banana Bread Donna Hay Wholesome Banana Bread 24 7.70 6.32 14.02 1.12 1250 Brown sugar, spelt flour, raising agents (sodium acid pyrophosphate (450), sodium carbonate (500)), rice flour, cinnamon, natural flavour. 2 eggs, 160mL oil, 1.5 cups bananas (about 4)
Homemade banana bread (Fiona's recipe) 42 na na 6.05 0.62 970 Banana, wheat flour, brown sugar, butter, eggs, vanilla extract, bicarbonate of soda, cinnamon na
Lighthouse QuickBread Banana Bread Base Mix Lighthouse QuickBread Banana Bread Base Mix 6 2.50 2.94 5.44 0.62 880 Wheat flour [vitamin (thiamin)], sugar, dark brown sugar, raising agents (339, 341, 450, 500), canola oil [antioxidant (319)], cinnamon, natural banana flavour, salt. 2 eggs, 60mL butter, 125mL milk, 2 bananas
White Wings Banana Bread White Wings Banana Bread 8 4.00 1.19 5.19 0.68 768 Wheat flour, (thiamin, folic acid), sugar, dried banana (9%), molasses powder, raising agents (450, 500, 341), salt, natural flavours (milk). 2 eggs, 125mL oil, 175mL milk

Table notes 

na not applicable 

(A) Pack includes sachet of passionfruit curd to make passionfruit butter (need to add your own butter). Not used in tasting. 

* Price paid (excluding specials) in Sydney supermarkets in July 2017. 

** As per Woolworths online shopping site in July 2017. 

*** As prepared, according to pack. Weight of our homemade banana bread is the average of two prepared loaves.

Fiona's banana bread recipe

Fiona's banana bread (home made)
Fiona's banana bread (minus a few slices!)

Ingredients

  • 125g butter, softened
  • 1 cup (175g) brown sugar
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
  • 2 eggs, lightly beaten
  • 2 cups mashed banana (approx. 4 small)
  • 1¾ cup (225g) self-raising flour, sifted
  • 1 teaspoon bicarbonate of soda
  • ¼ teaspoon ground cinnamon 
Method 
  1. Preheat oven to 160°C (325°F) and grease and line a 21cm x 14cm (2 litre capacity) loaf tin.
  2. Place the butter, sugar and vanilla in the bowl of an electric mixer and beat for 1–2 minutes or until pale and creamy. Scrape down the sides of the bowl. This can be done by hand if you don't have an electric mixer
  3. Add the eggs and beat well to combine. Then add the banana, flour, bicarbonate of soda, and cinnamon, stir to combine.
  4. Spoon into prepared tin and bake for 55–60 minutes, or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean.
  5. Cool in the tin for 20 minutes before turning out onto a wire rack. Cut into slices to serve.
Makes approx. 970g loaf.


Leave a comment

Display comments