Skip to content   Skip to footer navigation 

Home and contents insurance comparison

Buy smarter with CHOICE membership

Join CHOICE

Or Learn more

Last updated: 17 September 2025
Fact-checked

Fact-checked

Checked for accuracy by our qualified verifiers and subject experts. Find out more about fact-checking at CHOICE.

Compare over 60 home insurers from across the market to help you find the right cover for your building and contents. Our comparison includes policies offered by Apia, NRMA, GIO, QBE, Budget Direct, Youi and more.

No phone calls, no commissions. Unlike other insurance comparison websites, we don't get paid by any of the insurers we're comparing. This means you sometimes won't see price scores for insurers like NRMA and RACV, but it also means we don't recommend insurers based on how much they pay comparison websites. We only recommend the best insurance policies for you.

Read more

Top 5 Building and Contents Insurance FAQs for Australian Homeowners

1. How much does home insurance cost and how can I save money?

Home insurance costs vary dramatically based on location and risk factors. For a house in suburban Adelaide, the cheapest offer was $345 a year, while in high-risk areas like the NSW Great Lakes region, the best price was $34,000. Shopping around can save thousands – the difference between cheapest and most expensive policies ranges from $1,504 in South Australia to $4,429 in North Queensland. Key money-saving strategies include: shopping around annually to avoid the loyalty penalty (new customers often get better deals), increasing your excess to $1,000-$1,500 (can reduce premiums by about 10% for every $500 increase), paying annually instead of monthly (saves 10-25%), and looking for discounts like bundling policies or security system installations.

2. How much coverage do I need and what's the difference between policy types?

You need to determine your 'sum insured' figure – the dollar value to completely repair, rebuild and replace everything. Most policies are sum insured policies that pay claims up to the specified amount. Safety net policies offer additional protection with up to 30% extra coverage above your sum insured in case of total loss. Total replacement policies (now rare) pay whatever it costs to rebuild regardless of your sum insured. Use your insurer's online calculator to determine your sum insured, as different insurers include different costs (like demolition and debris removal) either within or on top of your coverage amount.

3. What does home insurance actually cover?

All policies cover standard insured events including fire and explosion, storm damage, lightning, theft, vandalism, impact damage, sudden escape of liquid (burst pipes), and accidental breakage of glass and ceramics. Flood cover is now included in most policies by default, even in low-risk areas. However, coverage for extreme weather varies significantly – many insurers exclude 'actions of the sea' (high tides, storm surges, tidal waves), and fire cover definitions differ regarding damage from heat, ash, smoke or soot from nearby bushfires. Always check your Product Disclosure Statement for specific definitions and exclusions.

4. Should I get building insurance, contents insurance, or both?

Building cover is essential if you own your house – it's typically required by your mortgage lender. If you're a renter, building insurance is your landlord's responsibility. In strata properties, building insurance is covered through the strata plan, though you may need to check what fixtures and fittings are included. Contents insurance covers your belongings and is recommended for both homeowners and renters. You can buy building-only, contents-only, or combined policies. Many insurers offer discounts for combining coverage, but ensure both policies meet your needs rather than just chasing the discount.

5. How do I choose the best insurer and avoid common pitfalls?

According to CHOICE's consumer survey of 1,200 respondents, RACQ was the top-rated insurer, followed by RAC, RAA, RACV, Apia, Youi, Suncorp, GIO and NRMA. However, the best insurer for you depends on your specific needs and location. Key tips include: getting quotes from at least three insurers (some will match competitors' prices), checking your renewal price against new customer quotes from your current insurer, reading the fine print for definitions and exclusions, keeping detailed records and photos of your belongings, and understanding that cheaper isn't always better – focus on policies that provide adequate coverage for your circumstances. Remember that 87% of policyholders saw premium increases at renewal, making annual comparison shopping essential.

Show less

Brand

Expand to view more details.

List of brands we tested in this review.

    enter value/s in increments of 1 between 0 and 0

    Recommended products

    Remove product

    Member only

    This test score is for members only. Join now to unlock our expert results.

    Already a member?

    Price score

    Expand to view more details.

    The higher the percentage score, the cheaper the policy compared to other products. This score is across all policies Australia wide, but premiums can differ a lot, depending on where you live. Check the $ sign price rating for your region or state to find a closer price indication for your home. "N/A" means the insurer doesn't operate here, or doesn't participate in the premium sharing program we use to collect pricing data.

    enter value/s in increments of i between 16 and 84

    Sold in North Queensland

    Expand to view more details.

    North Queensland means north of the Tropic of Capricorn.

      Sold in South Australia

        Sold in South Queensland

        Expand to view more details.

        South Queensland means south of the Tropic of Capricorn.

          Sold in Western Australia

          Expand to view more details.

          North WA means north of the Tropic of Capricorn.

            Included in this review

            Members-only access
            • Recommended
            • CHOICE Expert Rating
            • Cover score
            • Price score
            • Good points
            • Bad points
            • About the insurer
            • Claims satisfaction
            • Customer satisfaction
            • Building cover
            • Contents cover
            • Legal liability cover
            • Pay-by-the-month charge
            • ACT price comparison
            • NSW price comparison
            • NT price comparison
            • North Queensland price comparison
            • South Queensland price comparison
            • SA price comparison
            • Tasmania price comparison
            • Victoria price comparison
            • WA price comparison
            • Cover for theft
            • Cover for fire
            • Cover for flood
            • Cover for storm and cyclone
            • Cover for storm surge
            • Cover for action of the sea
            • Cover for tsunami
            • Cover for explosion
            • Cover for earthquake
            • Cover for vandalism
            • Cover for impact
            • Cover for animal damage
            • Cover for sudden escape of liquid
            • Cover for accidental breakage of glass
            • Cover for accidental damage
            • How to claim
            • Settling your claim
            • Cash settlements for building claims
            • Cash settlements for contents claims
            • New for old replacement
            • Motor burnout
            • Key/lock replacement after theft
            • Gardens and landscaping
            • Costs to comply with building regulations
            • Professional fees
            • Mortgage discharge fees
            • Debris removal and demolition
            • Temporary accomodation
            • Cover for unspecified portable contents
            • Optional cover for individual portable valuables
            • Contents in the open air
            • Emergency storage
            • Jewellery
            • Artworks
            • Collections (e.g. stamps, coins)
            • Digital media
            • Spoiled food
            • Visitors' contents
            • Pet cover
            • Overlapping cover at a new house
            • Cover for contents while moving house
            • Fire, storm and theft
            • Flood
            • Underinsurance protection

            Results

            Your filters

            Clear all filters

            Product selected for a detailed comparison

            Clear all

            Get full access to all our tests and reviews

            or Log in