Stick vs corded vacuums


Is a stick vacuum all you need? CHOICE crunches the data.


Is it time to write off barrel and upright vacuums that rely on mains power now that battery-powered stick vacs are on the rise?

Cordless stick vacuums are fast becoming a popular home appliance. We saw a huge marketing shift towards cordless in 2018, when Dyson announced it was no longer developing traditional corded vacuums because it sees the future as battery driven.

In our CHOICE lab tests, we've seen an improvement in stick vacuum performance overall since we began testing them almost a decade ago – and these days, some high end models actually outperform their corded counterparts on carpet. But there is variability: some of the worst performers are no substitute for a traditional vacuum.

CHOICE verdict

We've crunched the data from our tests, and unless you're willing to pay big bucks for a top-end stick vacuum (and aren't bothered about frequently emptying it) we reckon it's not quite time to get rid of your traditional vacuum just yet for those big cleans.

Which vacuums are better at picking up dust?

Winner (for now): Traditional vacuum

At first glance, there isn't much between stick and vacuum performance when we look at our average test scores for vacuuming on carpet:

 Average CHOICE vacuum cleaning scores from 2018-19

 Vacuum type

 Thorough cleaning on carpet

Quick cleaning on carpet 

 Stick (cordless)

 72%

 65%

 Traditional (corded)

 73%

 65%


But these figures are somewhat skewed by higher-end stick vacuums which can often perform just as well, and even better, than their corded cousins. For example, our top performing stick vacuum scores 91% for thorough carpet clean performance, equal to our top performing barrel vacuum.

So although some stick vacuums are definitely a substitute for a full vacuum – and the performance gap is closing – we can't say that's the case for most models out there. Since we have to choose, the barrel/upright still wins.

Bosch, Dyson, Electrolux, Hoover, LG and more

See our expert product reviews

Traditional vacuum reviews

Which vacuums are easier to maintain?

Winner: Traditional vacuum

Stick vacuums have smaller dust bins (0.2 litres to 0.7 litres) so they will need frequent emptying and should not be filled beyond the max line. Empyting the bin after each use and cleaning the filters regularly (which can often be fiddly) will help maintain performance for most models.

Some models such as the Dyson V11 and Dyson V10 will indicate when the filter (or filters) need changing, but most stick vacuums won't do this. You'll probably only realise they need changing when you see a decrease in performance.

Mains-powered vacuums usually have a far greater dust capacity; the average measurement is about 1.9 litres – many dust bags from the Miele range, for example, have a huge 3-litre capacity.

Which vacuums are best for pet hair?

Winner: Traditional vacuum

Back in 2010, many of the stick vacuums we tested still left the odd clump of pet hair on the carpet, and results on average were only OK. While we test on different carpet these days and can't compare results directly, we are seeing excellent results for pet hair removal from carpet in general when the vacuums are on their strongest settings. This suggests that both the suction and design of the power heads has improved over time.

However, cats and dogs shed a lot of hair, so although many of the stick vacuums we test these days do a great job, you might find yourself emptying the smaller receptacle more often, which can be a pain and unhelpful if you suffer from allergies. What's more, the battery might not last long enough for you to pick up all the hair. Putting the vacuum on a lower setting can help it last longer, but it may not pick up as much hair as you'd like. A traditional bagged vacuum will contain the pet hair when disposed, and both bagged and bagless vacs won't need to be emptied as frequently.

For all types of vacuums, models may struggle if they don't come with a motorised turbo brush or power head to really grab the hair that's embedded in the carpet.

Which vacuums are easier to use?

Winner: Stick vacuum

Stick vacuums we've tested have an average weight of just 2.9kg compared with 7.1kg for corded models, so for ease of moving around the house, it's clear to see why stick vacuums have become so popular.

Cleaning your car is easy with a stick vacuum. With most models the body detaches from the wand and you can easily add a crevice or upholstery tool to suck up pesky pebbles and dirt. Some of the tools are flexible, so you can really get into tight spaces with ease.

The other bonus, of course, is you're cord-free and ready to go. For quick cleans, there's no contest. While there are exceptions, regular vacuums have a limited reach of between 9 or 10 metres on average, so you'll need to plug and unplug.

Looking for the best stick vacuum?

See our expert product reviews

Stick vacuum reviews

Don't stick vacuums run out of juice?

Winner: Traditional vacuum

Stick vacuums can conk out quite suddenly when you least expect it. On average, batteries take 4.5 hours to charge for just 13 minutes of use on full power. Thankfully, the situation is getting easier to manage with many models. 

For instance, swappable batteries are standard with some brands. Ryobi's stick vacuum comes with an easy-to-remove battery that's also compatible with its family of tools, so you can keep a charged-up spare hanging around. And LG's top-end A9 models have a dual power pack so you can charge one battery in the dock while the other's in use, then swap over when needed.

Dyson's batteries are still integrated with their units, but the latest V11 models have an LCD screen with a countdown timer to let you monitor power levels.

If you're well-prepared, a stick vacuum can see you through a household clean, but it doesn't compare with the constant power-source of a corded vac.

Which vacuums are noisiest?

Its a tie

It depends. Vacuums may have a number of suction settings, so we test them at their loudest, strongest settings. On that basis, we don't actually see a discernible difference between corded and stick, with both types measuring 73dB on average.

Which vacuums are better value?

Winner: Traditional vacuum

Our test results reveal that price isn't necessarily an indicator of performance. While some stick vacuums will set you back more than $900, we've reviewed some at far lower price points that still do a very good job. You do tend to get more value out of a traditional vacuum, though.

More about vacuums


Leave a comment

Display comments