Though the Surface's active noise cancellation is pretty damn impressive, the sound quality, smart functions and controls are pretty middle of the road, and you can only access all the features and tools with a Windows 10 device. Unless you're a staunch Microsoft fan who's heavily embedded in the Windows ecosystem, there's nothing particularly enticing here.
Rating: 3.5 stars
- Wireless connectivity via Bluetooth
- Active noise cancellation (ANC)
- Up to 15 hours of battery life (for noise cancellation and Bluetooth)
- Touch and physical controls on the headphones – to adjust volume, ACN, and interact with the connected device (skip songs, answer phone calls etc.)
- Inbuilt microphone for phone calls
- Cortana, Siri and Google Assistant support
Though the Surface headphones can connect to basically any Bluetooth audio source, Windows 10 devices get a little bonus in the form of an exclusive app. However, it's fairly bare bones, with little more than a basic equalisation, and added voice commands for supported software, such as Spotify.
And while Bluetooth should suit the needs of most users streaming songs from Spotify, Apple Music and so on, there's no Wi-Fi or high resolution audio support.
Ports and plugs
If you prefer to keep things old school, or don't want to deal with Bluetooth compression, you can connect via:
- USB-C, for charging and audio
- 3.5mm auxiliary cable, for audio
These inputs can power the headphones as well, even if the battery dies, which makes for a handy backup, but Bluetooth and active noise-cancellation won't work without a charge.
How do they sound?
As far as audio quality goes, the Surface headphones aren't half bad at pumping out popular music. Top 40 type tunes, with a bit of bass and vocal forward production, as well as podcasts etc., sound good.
But they're a bit underwhelming otherwise.
- The Surface headphones are bassy, very bassy, so much so that music with a lot of low-end can feel a little muffled.
- Most tones in the high-end, particularly treble, are pretty reserved, which really impacts punchy guitars in classic and modern rock songs.
- Once you introduce more than a handful of instruments, or music that's meticulous, fast or intricate such as classical, jazz, hard electronica or metal, everything becomes pretty jumbled and it's difficult to discern the details.
- It all sounds a bit flat, and otherwise dynamic tracks take a hit, especially in the high-end.
- The equalisation tool can improve things, but it's too basic to make any effective adjustments. Not that it really matters, as Android and iOS users can't access it anyway.
It's still a relatively pleasant listening experience, but there are other similarly priced headphones that are much better at handling dynamic music (such as the Sony WH-1000XM3s).
Can they cancel noise?
What the Surface headphones lack in audio dynamics, they make up for in active noise-cancellation. We tested them in various environments including an office, footpath adjacent to a busy street, and a seat above the wing on a domestic flight, and the ANC reduced these environments to a dull hum every time. Once you start playing something, it's hardly noticeable.
ANC is activated by rotating a wheel on the left cup. It's a simple, natural and intuitive solution.
13 levels of noise cancellation
As you roll the wheel clockwise (towards your head), it increases the level of ambient noise. This is for people that don't like the feeling of total isolation, or if you require some environmental sounds for safety reasons, such as spatial awareness.
Ambient noise doesn't interfere with music until about two-thirds of the way through the rotation. At the higher levels however, the ambient amplification gets a little too extreme, and almost sounds like the jet engine these headphones are so good at cancelling.
The cup design should fit comfortably around most people's ears, offering some degree of passive noise cancellation. So even if you find yourself with a dead battery you won't have to endure all the dreadful sounds of day-to-day life.
Features and functions
There's a broad set of features and functions crammed into the Surface headphones, and they're implemented relatively well, save for a few small oversights.
Controls on the cups
The ACN wheel
A volume wheel on the right hand side
Touch controls on each can, which you can activate by tapping/placing your finger on the surface (these include play, pause, song skip, and answer and decline phone calls)
The headphones will automatically pause when you take them off your head (or hang the headphones around your neck)
Touch controls work most of the time, but they require some additional taps now and then which is frustrating. They also sound like a drum inside your head, so while they're handy for skipping a song or two, you're unlikely to use them very often.
Inbuilt microphones can detect your voice for phone calls and commands, but commands will only work if you're connected to a device with a digital assistant.
- Cortana is built into the headphones, and can be used for advanced commands and user customisation. However you'll still need an external device for it to function.
- Google Assistant and Siri can be used for basic commands and simple tasks such as checking the weather or skipping songs, also via an external device.
The voice commands work, but adding additional functions for Cortana alienates the rest of the market. On the one hand, it's understandable given that Microsoft wants to push its own products. But at the same time, you can't aim an item at the entire market, then expect most people to pay full price for half of the features.
Connect to multiple devices
The Surface headphones can connect to multiple Bluetooth devices at once, which is especially useful for taking calls. Say someone rings while you're listening to music from your PC. As long as you're connected to your smartphone as well, the call will stop the music on your computer so you can answer.
Design and comfort
The Surface headphones are hardly flashy, instead, Microsoft has opted for the minimalist grey and white hues that have appeared across a number of its products as of late. Still, style is subjective, but when it comes to comfort, they are a little tight on the old noggin for those of us with larger craniums. Similarly, the cups are relatively roomy, but can constrain bigger ears.
Things are otherwise fairly standard and easy to use, though there is one design flaw for people that like to hang headphones around their neck. The cans rotate upwards, rather than face down, which causes two problems:
- The speakers are exposed
- The touch panel rests on your collarbone, which can activate it
Small issues in the grand scheme of things, but they could have easily been avoided had the headphones spun the other way.
Are they worth buying?
Wireless headphones have become a very competitive market, and when you factor in the best models from Sony and Bose, the Surface headphones don't really stand out. Audio quality is fine, functionality is fine, battery life is fine, the added features for Windows and Cortana users are fine if you buy into the whole Windows environment. It's all just fine.
It would be surprising if extra features for Windows 10 and Cortana would be enough to entice customers to move from Android or iOS into a new ecosystem. However, there is enough there to make it seem like Microsoft is asking non-Windows users to pay the same amount for an incomplete set of features. It's a strange move, and one that winds up feeling like a punishment for people that don't fully invest in Microsoft products. There is really only one company that seems to be able to get away with this closed approach (think fruit).
There are no glaring flaws here, but aside from the outstanding active noise cancellation, there's no compelling reason to pick up the Surface headphones either.