Skip to content   Skip to footer navigation 

The bad value health insurance deals from the biggest health funds: CHOICE

CHOICE reveals the poor value for money health insurance policies from Medibank, Bupa, HBF, HCF and NIB.

CHOICE has analysed thousands of policies and found that many of the biggest health funds are selling some policies that offer terrible value for customers.

"80% of Australians with health insurance are insured by one of five big health funds - Medibank, Bupa, HBF, HCF and NIB. However, having a policy with one of these big, well-known funds doesn't guarantee that you're getting a good deal on your health insurance," says CHOICE health insurance expert, Dean Price. 

"There are some really poor value policies on offer at all of the big health funds, and it can often be very difficult to know exactly which ones these are," says Price.

"The main problem with a lot of these poor value health insurance policies is that they provide you with less cover than a cheaper policy does," says Price. 

TkoKknPF8QC6ZIHaC8xouCI4aOwsyheVfs7u3yS_PrvWYA-wgJsahGRP5KuwzKE9pf4EhXJ3b_g_XhVtIHP_HQutfy9cmloDpzNNkfKSBjMrxZa-fZc5sdMdHvSZsyhJeRCqNBZh

Infographic available for embedding here: https://infogram.com/bad-value-health-policies-1ho16vykkedv6nq?live

Medibank's bad value policies 

Medibank Basic Accident and Ambulance 

"The Medibank Basic Accident and Ambulance policy only covers you in the event of an accident, along with providing public hospital cover for some services. 

In NSW, the ACT, TAS and WA, this policy costs more than the cheapest Bronze policy, which covers you for essential services in private hospitals like breast and prostate cancer surgery," says Price.

Medibank Silver Plus Security

"The Medibank Silver Plus Security policy has restricted or zero cover for some services, such as pregnancy and psychiatric treatment. It is also more expensive in all states than the cheapest Gold policy that completely covers all treatments," says Price.

Bupa's bad value policies

Bupa Accident Only

"Our experts found that the Bupa Accident Only policy provides only a basic level of cover, but costs more than the cheapest Bronze policy in NSW, the ACT, SA, TAS and WA. The Bronze policy would provide you with a higher level of cover for less money," says Price.

Bupa Silver Plus

"The Bupa Silver Plus policy is more expensive in all states except WA and NT than the cheapest Gold policy that fully covers all treatments," says Price.

HBF's bad value policies

HBF Bronze Hospital Plus

"The HBF Bronze Hospital Plus policy doesn't cover heart surgery, despite the fact that coronary heart disease is the biggest cause of death in Australia. In WA, it's more expensive than the cheapest Silver policy, which covers heart disease and more," says Price.

HBF Silver Hospital Plus

"The HBF Silver Hospital Plus policy is more expensive than the cheapest Gold policy in all states except SA, TAS and WA. The Gold policy covers all treatments, while the HBF policy has restricted or no cover for some services including pregnancy and psychiatric treatment," says Price.

HCF's bad value policies 

HCF Accident Only Basic

"In NSW, ACT and TAS, the HCF Accident Only Basic policy costs more than the cheapest Bronze cover policy. The Bronze policy covers you for essential services in private hospitals, while HCF's Accident Only Basic only covers you in the event of an accident, and provides public hospital cover for some services," says Price.

HCF Hospital Silver Plus 

"The HCF Hospital Silver Plus policy is more expensive in all states than the cheapest Gold policy which completely covers all treatments," says Price. 

NIB's bad value policy 

NIB Silver Advantage Hospital Plus

"In all states except SA and WA, NIB's Silver Advantage Hospital Plus policy is more expensive than the cheapest Gold policy which covers all treatments," says Price.

Media contact: Katelyn Cameron, media@choice.com.au, 0430 172 668 

To read the full story, click here: www.choice.com.au/badpolicies

Editor's notes:

How did we select the policies? 

We selected policies from the five biggest funds that are bad value for money in at least one of the biggest states (NSW, VIC, QLD), or in the state where the large majority of the members of the fund reside. Bad value means:

- Silver and Silver Plus policies that provide less cover and cost more than the cheapest Gold policy in the same state.

- Bronze and Bronze Plus policies that provide less cover and are more expensive than the cheapest Silver policy in their state.

- Basic and Basic Plus policies that provide less cover and are more expensive than the cheapest Bronze policy in the same state.