Want More?
This report is for members only.
Member-only content

Fridge reviews

We put the major refrigerators through their paces in our laboratories.
 
Get access to all CHOICE BENEFITS
$1.91/wk
*Billed quarterly
 
 
 
 

01.Introduction

fridges-lead-nov-2012

We review 58 fridges priced from $499 to $4999.

Through our rigorous testing we reveal which fridges perform the best. Use this report to: 

On this page:

For more information about Fridges and freezers, see Kitchen.

CHOICE's experts independently test a wide range of products and services to bring you unbiased reviews, product comparison tools and buying advice that is trusted by 140,000+ members.
Get access to all
CHOICE benefits.
$1.91
/week
Subscribe to Choice
*Billed quarterly

Video: Fridges - what to look for

CHOICE explains some of the key things to keep in mind when purchasing a fridge, especially with regard to temperature settings.


Fridge brands and models tested

Beko DN143120
Bosch KAN62V00AU
Bosch KGN53X70AU
Daewoo FR360
Daewoo FR-4501W
Daewoo FRS-U20ICW
Electrolux EBM4300SC
Electrolux EBM4307SC
Electrolux EBM5100SC
Electrolux EBM5107SC
Electrolux EHE5107SA
Electrolux EQE6007SB-NAU
Electrolux ETM4407SC
Fisher and Paykel E249TR
Fisher and Paykel E331T
Fisher and Paykel E381TRT2
# Fisher and Paykel E402BRE3
Fisher and Paykel E411T
# Fisher and Paykel E442BRE3
# Fisher and Paykel E522BRE3
# Fisher and Paykel RF522WDRX1
Haier HRFZ-213
Haier HSBS562IS
Haier HSBS582AS
Haier HTD647AS
Kelvinator KBM4300WB
Kelvinator KSM6100WF
LG GC-305PS
LG GC-L197STF
LG GC-P197DPSL
LG GN-253VW
LG GN-422FW
LG GR-L219CSL
LG GR-L247DPSL
# LG GR-L730SL
Midea HD-496FWS
Panasonic NR-BW465VWAU
Samsung SR215MW
Samsung SR364MW
Samsung SR388MW
Samsung SR394NW
Samsung SR432NW
Samsung SR434MNP
Samsung SR511ENW
Samsung SRL322MW
Samsung SRF527DSLS
Samsung SRF801GDLS
Samsung SRS585HDIS
Samsung SRS600NLS
Samsung SRS684GDHSS
Samsung SRS691GDIS
Westinghouse WBE4300SB
Westinghouse WBM4300WB
# Westinghouse WBM5100WC
Westinghouse WSE7000WF
Westinghouse WTB2300WB
Westinghouse WTB2500WB
Westinghouse WTM2000WC

# Newly tested models.

How we test

Overall score
  • Temperature performance (broken down below): 80%
  • Energy efficiency: 20%

A good temperature for a fridge is 3°C, and for a freezer -18°C. The temperature performance score is a measure of the fridge’s ability to manage basic cooling temperatures in all compartments, and is based on the following factors:

  • Temperature fluctuations Do temperatures fluctuate too much due to the compressor running and stopping? (30%)
  • Temperature range Is there an adequate range of temperature combinations to satisfy the needs of most users? (25%)
  • Ambient change Can the fridge and freezer cope with changes in the outside temperature? (20%)
  • Temperature uniformity Are compartment temperatures generally uniform, without warmer or colder areas? (20%)
  • Recommended settings Is the temperature for both the fridge and freezer appropriate when the controls are set to the manufacturer's recommended or 'mid' setting? (5%)
Energy consumption / energy efficiency score

This test assesses the comparative energy consumption, and gives an indication of the amount of electricity used over one year of normal operation. The energy efficiency score is based on the measured energy consumption and is adjusted depending on the volume of the fresh-food and freezer compartments.

For side-by-side fridges, the energy used is measured with any icemaker off, as the standard requires. Icemaking will use a little extra energy, and if you make a lot of ice you can expect a slight increase in energy consumption and running costs.

Quietness / noise

New fridges, particularly frost-free ones, make a combination of noises that some people may find annoying. More noise is produced when the compressor starts up and also during the defrost cycle. Some models have an external fan system to help keep the compressor cool, which can add to the noise level. Also, plastics inside the fridge can make loud noises as they expand and contract with temperature changes. The design of your kitchen and the fridge’s location will affect what you’ll hear. Our test tells you which models are noisier during normal running, but some of these more unusual noises can be more noticeable with models that are quieter during normal running.

Claimed total volume

The gross volume quoted by the manufacturer tells you approximately how much air space the fridge has to cool, which includes spaces you can’t put food into. Taking this into account, use the volumes to get an idea of how big the freezer is compared with the fresh-food compartment so you can choose a fridge that meets your storage needs.

For side-by-side fridges with an icemaker and through the door dispenser, the usable freezer volume is approximately 30% less than claimed, due to space taken by the icemaker, so the claimed total volume is overstated too.

Running costs over 10 years

The running cost is calculated from the energy used over 10 years, using a rate of 26 cents per kilowatt hour. A 10-year period provides a useful indication of the long-term differences between high and low energy usage.

Price

This is a recommended retail price unless otherwise specified. You can probably get a better price by shopping around.

Defrost system

All the listed fridges are frost-free (unless otherwise noted). This means the refrigerator/freezer automatically defrosts around every 12 hours or so, but it depends on the model and how hard it's been working.

Dimensions

These are claimed dimensions for the smallest box that will fit around the fridge, that is, it includes hinges, door handles and any protrusions at the back, such as the compressor.

The installation space is the minimum total space recommended to allow air to circulate around the fridge for optimum energy use and performance. If there is no gap at the rear of overhead cabinets, then the recommended space above may increase by about 40mm. Many fridges are designed to sit proud of the cabinetry, so you will often find that the required depth is less than the the depth of the fridge.

Door hinge position

This is the side of the fridge that the door hinge is positioned, as well as the direction that the door opens. With many models you'll have to pre-order it on either the left or right, and it isn't reversible after purchase. But some are reversible: while you can do this yourself with some models, manufacturers recommend getting a service call. Reversible doors are useful if you move house and/or need to position the fridge differently.

Save money on your new fridge

Our report will save you money for years to come and goes beyond the sales hype to reveal:

  • Which of the smaller fridges perform best.
  • How to save hundreds of dollars on running costs every year.
  • Which brands need the least repairs.

Choose the right fridge for you

No need to rely on a salesperson. Use this report to decide:

  • What type of fridge will suit your needs: top freezer, bottom freezer, side by side?
  • What optional features you need and what you can do without.
Want more?
Get access to our independent testing reports and save yourself time and money.
Subscribe to Choice
 
 

 
 
Your say - Choice voice

Make a Comment

Members – Sign in on the top right to contribute to comments