Member-only content

Home espresso coffee machine reviews

Which machines will deliver the perfect cup of coffee at home?
 
Get access to all CHOICE BENEFITS
$1.91/wk
*Billed quarterly
 
 
 
  • Updated:20 Dec 2012
  • Author:Rebecca Ciaramidaro
  • rateraterateraterate: Member rating
 

01 .Introduction

Breville ESP8C Café Roma espresso machine

Here, we have test results for 23 manual and semi-automatic espresso machines, including six capsule machines priced from $70 to $1750.

On this page, you'll find:

Through our rigorous testing, we reveal which coffee machines:

  • Make the best tasting coffee
  • Are the easiest to use
  • Make the best frothed milk
  • Are able to maintain consistent coffee temperature over consecutive cups.

Australians love our coffee – possibly a little too much. According to Appliance Retailer magazine, a staggering 36% of us consume five or more cups of coffee a day. But whether or not we’re drinking too much, it’s certainly important to us that we drink good coffee, and that’s where these machines come in.

A 30mL shot of espresso forms the base of any coffee. You should use fresh coffee beans and grind them just before use, which means you'll need a coffee grinder

Video: How we test espresso machines

CHOICE takes a close look at the next generation of espresso machines and talks about what to look for in a good machine. For more information see our latest test results.

CHOICE takes a close look at the next generation of espresso machines and talks about what to look for in a good machine. For more information see our latest test results.espresso-machines-how-we-test


In this test, we cover four types of coffee machine:

  • Semi-automatic and manual machines are for those who want to experiment with their coffee. A semi-automatic model will automatically cut off the flow of coffee once a preset amount has been poured into the cup, whereas you have total control with a manual machine and need to cut the flow of coffee yourself.
  • There’s also one hand pump machine on test, which works on the same principles as a manual machine except that you need to use a pump action to push the water through the ground coffee. 
  • Capsule machines use a coffee capsule filled with enough coffee for a single shot. These machines are easy to use - you simply insert the capsule and the machine pierces it to allow hot water to flow through and make the shot. While Nespresso still dominates this market, there are many other players now entering the market with even Woolworths and Aldi releasing more affordable versions. Pleasingly, two on test deliver great quality and make our What to Buy list. 

Premium coffee

In the past we've used an easy-to-access supermarket brand of coffee for our taste test. But for this test, we’ve changed the coffee we use to a premium product. Since previously tested models can no longer be compared directly we’ve re-tested many of them here.  

Models tested

  • Breville Cafe Venezia BES250
  • Breville The Barista Express BES860
  • Breville The Dual Boiler BES900
  • Breville The Infuser BES840
  • Bugatti 15-Diva CM
  • DeLonghi EC860.M
  • DeLonghi Icona ECO310.W
  • DeLonghi Lattissima+ EN520.S (Nespresso)
  • Electrolux Lavazza A Modo Mio ELM5250S
  • Expobar Office SA
  • Expressi K-fee (Aldi)
  • La Pavoni Eurobar EBR24A
  • La Pavoni Stradivari Lusso V230 STL
  • Map Bella SO4 Caffitaly System
  • Map S02HS Perfecto Caffitaly System
  • Philips Saeco Poemia HD8327
  • Rancilio Miss Silvia V3
  • Saeco Via Venezia Inox
  • Sunbeam Cafe Crema II EM4820
  • Sunbeam Cafe Series EM6910
  • Sunbeam Cafe Series EM7000
  • Sunbeam Espresso Vita EM6200
  • Woolworths Caffitaly Coffee Machine S14

How we test

Our tester, Peter Horvath, scores each of the coffee machines on:
  • Taste (rated in a blind taste test by three coffee experts)
  • Ease of use (including ease of programming, controls, group handle/filter and refilling with water and coffee)
  • Frothing milk for lattes and cappuccinos
  • Coffee temperature consistency over consecutive cups

To remove any factory smells and tastes, Peter pumps a litre of hot water through each of the machines, then makes 12 cups of espresso coffee (not for testing), one after another.

Capsule machines for these machines Peter chooses the capsule flavour that best resembles an espresso shot. He tries most (if not all) of the flavours supplied for a particular machine before he chooses which capsule will be used for the test.

Meet our experts

For our taste test we've recruited the expert palates of David and Matthew Gee from Barista Basics and our home economist, Fiona Mair. They taste a 30mL shot of espresso from each machine in a blind taste test and assess each shot by looking at the colour and thickness of the crema, the aroma, flavour, mouthfeel and aftertaste. We use a reference machine to check the consistency of our taste testers. Peter uses single wall baskets where supplied (double wall if no single is supplied) and an ECM grinder to get the right grind.

$name 

For more information on coffee products, see grinders and coffee roasters.

 
 

 

Tamping tips

Tamping compresses your coffee in the filter basket, allowing the pressurised water to flow through the espresso evenly to give you a quality shot. An incorrect tamp can result in a poor-quality shot.

  • Dose the ground coffee into the filter and place the filter on a flat, stable surface. Hold the filter in one hand and gently level the coffee with the other.
  • Apply the first tamp. While holding the filter, hold the tamper firmly in the other hand. Place the tamper on top of the coffee so it’s parallel to the surface and press downwards.

The jury is still out on whether you should apply the final tamp. Our tester, Peter Horvath, says one firm tamp should be enough, followed by wiping the top of the filter basket to remove any loose coffee particles.

Coffee-making tips

  • When you have a new machine, flush about a litre of water through it to remove any factory flavours. Be sure to push a cup of hot water through the steam wand as well as the group head and the filter.
  • Once you have heated up the machine, switch the pump on and see how the hot water comes out without the group handle being attached to the group head. Some machines tend to overheat the boiler which makes the water too hot and produces too much steam, which can burn the coffee granules. If this is the case with your machine be sure to let some water out before making your coffee.
  • The standard amount of ground coffee for an espresso is 7 grams for 30mL of water. If you like your coffee stronger and with more flavour try increasing it to 8 or even 9 grams. Or try reducing the amount of water to about 20-25mL.
  • If you are making a short black don’t run more than 30mL of water through the machine as it will remove flavour and make the coffee too bitter.
  • Always use fresh water straight from the tap or bottled water that doesn’t have a chlorine flavour.
  • During the warm-up period keep the group handle in the group head so that every part of the machine that comes into contact with the coffee gets hot.
  • A warm cup keeps the coffee hot which in turn keeps milk coffee frothy. Some machines have an inbuilt cup warmer, but you can also just run some hot water from the machine into the cups instead.
  • Run a small amount of water though the machine after frothing milk to cool the internal parts down. This is important if you are going to make more coffees as the extra heat from the frothing process can burn the grind.

Milk-frothing tips

Since upwards of 90% of coffee beverages in Australia and New Zealand are milk-based, the frothing technique is an important part in making the perfect cup of coffee. Here are our tips for frothing milk.

  • Some machines come with a froth enhancer, and while it’s easy to use it often puts large bubbles into the milk, which is undesirable. Generally, a quality creamy and silky froth is achieved by following the correct technique without using the froth enhancer.
  • Use a small stainless steel jug and use cold milk straight from the fridge. Using warm milk will not give it enough time to froth. Inject steam until the milk reaches about 65°C; by then it should be the right texture for pouring. You should aim for the froth to stay stable for at least five minutes. Also, ensure you don’t heat the milk beyond 72°C or reheat it down the track. 
  • When using the steam wand, ensure you remove all condensation before placing it in the milk. Once you have dry steam, to avoid splattering you should put the tip of the wand into the milk and then raise it so it sits just below the surface. To spin the milk, tilt the jug slightly. 
  •  If you don’t have a thermometer, the milk is generally at the right temperature when you can no longer hold your hand at the bottom of the jug. However, a thermometer is a handy tool to have if you’re just starting out.
  • To break any air bubbles, tap and then swirl the jug around on your bench after frothing. You should then pour the milk into the cup immediately, before its texture changes. Tilt the cup slightly, and pour with a consistent speed.
  • As a matter of hygiene, the steam wand should always be wiped clean after use, to avoid possible cross-contamination and to remove crusted-on milk.

Video: Making a good espresso

A quick guide to getting the best espresso out of your new coffee machine.

A quick guide to getting the best espresso out of your new coffee machine.

2009_12_espresso_guide


Your say - Choice voice

Make a Comment

Members – Sign in on the top right to contribute to comments