Thank you to everyone who participated in trying to pick the $500 camera. For those who have not already looked, here are the latest results of the poll:
Lowlight photo 1
- 37% of the vote
Lowlight photo 2
- 34% of the vote
Lowlight photo 3
- 28% of the vote
Total votes = 210
With such an even split it's clear that the cheaper camera is not easily identified, because the images are not so different that everyone can see which is doing a better job.
We can now reveal that the $500 camera produced Lowlight photo 2
. Also, we can tell you that on our test scale it would score better than the other two cameras for this part of the test.
However, this is only one of the many tests that make up our image quality score and for overall picture quality the cameras that produced images one and three get better scores.
What does this tell us?
If you remove the dollar value and brand of the camera from the equation, the viewer has to rely on their understanding of what makes a good photo.
Our testers have the advantage of seeing the test target in both daylight and other light sources. As a result they have judged that Lowlight photo 2 is the best combination of white balance, exposure and noise in this instance.
The other two cameras clearly have not compensated for the overly warm light and you would have to do some work to correct this, if you have the skills and can be bothered.
Here is what happens when we manually set the ISO to ISO3200, do a manual white balance and exposure with the cameras that produced images one and two. They’re in the same order, so Lowlight manual 1 comes from the same camera as Lowlight photo 1 on the previous page.
This image is also part of our overall score and you can see the image Lowlight manual 2
is much noisier and has lost quite a bit of edge definition as a result.
It’s not possible to judge a camera on the basis of just one or two images. We produce dozens of images from every camera we test in a variety of circumstances designed to replicate normal usage. In addition we do technical tests that give an indication of how well the camera performs some more specific tasks (such as resolution to show how much detail a camera can record). We do this in both auto and manual modes for the cameras we include our high-end tests.
You can see the full tests by following the links below: