toggle
This report is for members and single purchase only.
Already a member? Sign in here

Not a member?

To access this expert review, join now for only $7.98 / month
(billed quarterly as $23.95 on a recurring basis until you cancel).

Member-only content

Children's convertible car seat reviews

Installing a child restraint correctly is the best way to prevent injuries to your child in a crash
To access this report, which includes CHOICE 'Best Buy' and an interactive comparision table, become a member now.
JOIN CHOICE or buy this single report: $23
 
Learn more
 
 
 
 
 

01.Introduction

CH0312_ChildCarSeats_lead033_MOD_WEB

We review 10 children's convertible car seats, suitable for your child from birth to four years of age and priced from $149 to $659.

Through our rigorous testing, we reveal which car seats:

  • Have buckles and seatbelts that are easy to adjust
  • Are the easiest to fit and tilt 
  • Are the easiest to clean

On this page you'll find:

For more information about children's Transport options, see Travel.

Disclaimer: CREP results


Your child’s safety is your priority, and when it comes to travelling in a car there’s a lot to take on board. What type of car restraint do you need? Does your car have the features to fit a restraint? What’s the law on car restraints? How do you fit the restraint and secure your child properly? These are all questions you’ll have to consider.

Recall update

20/11/2012: The ACCC (Australian Competition and Consumer Commission) has released a recall for over 60,000 child car seats due to safety concerns. See the full media release.

Road accidents are the major cause of deaths in children under 14 years, and research has found about 60% of children are incorrectly restrained in their seats. Common errors can involve the tether strap not being connected, the seatbelt incorrectly threaded or not buckled, or the anchorage point being used the wrong way.

Fitting your restraint

If you’re going to install the seat yourself make sure you follow the manufacturer’s instructions, but it’s certainly worthwhile visiting an authorised fitting station. These centres (listed on your state’s motoring organisation website) have experts that can inspect, adjust or fully install your restraint for a small fee. By using a restraint that’s correctly installed, you can significantly reduce the risk to your child in an accident.

Our tester and female triallist assessed 10 convertible child car restraints that are suitable from birth to four years of age, and most state a maximum weight of 18kg. 

You must place your baby in the rearward-facing mode while they’re under six months old; then between six and 12 months (depending on their size), the restraint can be converted to the forward-facing mode where your child will stay until they are at least four years old.

The Australian Standard and CREP

All seats sold in Australia must meet the requirements of Australian Standard AS/NZS 1754 which covers requirements for the design, construction, performance, user instructions, marking and packaging of child car restraints. The standard was last amended in May 2011 where an earlier 1995 version of the standard was removed and replaced with the 2010 version. Therefore the mandatory standard is now based on the 2000, 2004 and 2010 versions of the standard. 

The Child Restraint Evaluation Program (CREP) funded by government, and motoring organisations allow you to see which restraints go beyond the requirements of the standard. The program conducts simulated crash tests on restraints to provide consumers with information about the level of occupant protection in a crash as well as assessing how easy they are to ease. A rating (out of five) is then applied to all tested seats.

What's the law?

New rules rolled out in 2010 give children greater protection when travelling.

  • Under six months Children must be seated in a rearward-facing child restraint or infant capsule. 
  • Six months to four years old Children are to use a rear- or forward-facing car restraint with an inbuilt harness. Children under four years old can’t travel in the front seat of a vehicle with two or more rows.
  • Four to seven years Children are to use a forward-facing restraint or booster seat. 
  • If all back seats are occupied by children under four, a child between four and seven can occupy the front seat in a forward-facing restraint or booster seat. 
  • If your child is too tall or heavy for their age group’s restraint you can move them to the next restraint. 

Keep an eye out for upcoming CHOICE reviews on forward-facing restraints and booster seats. 

Models tested

  • Babylove Ezy Switch Charcoal BL72A/2010
  • Go Safe Cleo 4790
  • Infa-Secure Cosi-Safe CS40CS
  • Infa-Secure Style-Rider CS41SR
  • Mother's Choice Emperor #009802
  • Mother's Choice Carrera #008730
  • Safety 1st DB2010 Car Seat Nero GT #11657
  • Safe-N-Sound Meridian AHR Tilt&Adjust Head Rest 3509
  • Safe-N-Sound Platinum AHR Air Cushion 3515
  • ZuZu GS2010 Car Seat Lexington #011693

How we test

Ease of use Our tester, Peter Horvath, assessed each seat on fitting in both rearward and forward facing modes, clarity of instructions, adjustment of the seatbelt and buckles, ease of tilting and removing the seat and removing the cover for cleaning. He also asked a female to assess each seat for ease of use and took into consideration her comments. 

We were unable to conduct performance tests on these seats however all the seats in this test must pass the Australian Standard to be sold which has a performance aspect in it. We are hoping that CREP results will become available later in the year which we can add to this review to give some more information on how they perform. 

Useful contacts

For more information on child restraints, or to find your nearest fitting station, contact: 

Kidsafe Australia: www.kidsafe.com.au

NSW 

RTA Customer Service enquiry on 132213 or www.rta.nsw.gov.au 
NRMA Technical Advice on 131122 or www.mynrma.com.au

Victoria 

RACV Motoring Advice Line on 03 9790 2190 or www.racv.com.au 
TAC on www.howsafeisyourcar.com.au

Western Australia 

RACWA on 131703 or www.rac.com.au

Queensland 

Queensland Government – Transport and main roads www.tmr.qld.gov.au

South Australia 

Department for Transport, Energy and Infrastructure www.dtei.sa.gov.au

Northern Territory 

Northern Territory Transport Group www.roadsafety.nt.gov.au

ACT 

ACT Government Territory and Municipal Services www.tams.act.gov.au 

Want more?
Get access to our independent testing reports and save yourself time and money.
Purchase the Children's convertible car seat reviews report
Subscribe to Choice
 
 

 

Sign up to our free
e-Newsletter

Receive FREE email updates of our latest tests, consumer news and CHOICE marketing promotions.

 
Your say - Choice voice

Make a Comment

Members – Sign in on the top right to contribute to comments