Kids' bike reviews

Take care when choosing your child's bike.
 
Get access to all CHOICE BENEFITS
$1.91/wk
*Billed quarterly
 
 
 
 

05.What to look for

Construction Bikes should have consistent welds along the frame; avoid a bike where the welding looks patchy. Shake the bike to check if anything is loose or rattles. Check there are no sharp projections – wires, nuts and bolts should have covers if they project. 

Wheels Check they run true by lifting the bike or putting it upside down and spinning the wheels, both front and back. If a wheel is not running true, you’ll see a wobble as you look at it from the front or rear of the bike (see video below). This means it needs some adjustment. Also check to see whether it rubs against anything, including the brakes when they are not activated. If they do or are difficult to turn, this will make your child’s ride harder and less enjoyable, so ask the bike shop to adjust accordingly.  

Adjustment See just how much distance there is when you adjust the seat post. There should be a mark showing the maximum movement for the seat; if the adjustment is quite small, your child will outgrow it quicker than you might like and you’ll be up for a replacement bike. 

Brakes Look for back pedal brakes where the child can simply reverse their pedalling to stop. Rim brakes (with brake pads on front and/or rear wheels) are common on adult bikes, as children usually don’t have the strength to pull them and, in some cases, are too wide a hand grip for small hands. Before buying, check the brakes work effectively; for back pedal brakes, put the bike upside down and reverse the pedal movement; for front and rear rim brakes, push the bike forward when right side up and test by pulling the hand levers. If they’re not working well, ask for them to be adjusted. Front and rear rim brakes often have very small brake pads, and so wear out sooner. 

Value A more expensive bike does not guarantee better quality, as our testing shows. Often a well-known brand commands a higher price when a cheaper brand will serve just as well, and in some cases give better bang for your buck. 

 

 

Video: Kids' bikes test footage

A short video showing the difference between 'true' and 'not true' wheels.

A short video showing the difference between 'true' and 'not true' wheels.

Test footage of kids' bikes


See our Buying a kids bike guide.

What the experts say

The Felt 10-Base 18.5 was missing a chaingaurd which we consider to be a major failure. However the manufacturer insists this is the responsibility of their authorised dealers to fit these, as all are supplied with them when they are shipped to the dealer. Both Felt bikes on test also failed clause 2.14.2.3 (handbrake grip dimensions) of the standard. We also consider this to be a major failure because if the handbrake grips are too wide for small hands to grip it becomes a safety issue if the child needs to suddenly apply the brakes. The manufacturer has informed CHOICE that there is a small screw located near where the cable enters the lever, and if it is adjusted, it will pass the standard. The screw, allows the consumer to make adjustments if the child is having trouble gripping the handbrake. However, CHOICE believes that a safety requirement must be met at all possible adjustment settings, especially at the default setting, as this is the condition the consumer is most likely to receive the product in.

All the bikes have braking mechanisms; however our experts found some to be more poorly implemented than others. They also comment on taking extra care with steel components, if they are left out in the elements they can rust. One of our experts made comments on whether both front and rear wheels run ‘true’, and found a couple to be out slightly (see Video which shows the difference between ‘true’ and ‘not true’ wheels).

They find some of the bikes to have good features, others to be made using better components and others which are clearly price driven rather than quality focused. One of our experts says a coaster brake with front and rear handlebar brakes is a useful feature – it allows the child to make an easy transition to handbrakes when learning.

How to comment

Here's your chance to join in the debate. Just click in the comment box and let the CHOICE Community know what you think, or view all of the comments on this article.

Reporting offensive comments

If you see something offensive or something that just shouldn't be there, hit the report button and let us know immediately. View the Terms of use for user comments.

 

Make a Comment