Don’t leave travellers high and dry

Ministers must keep commitment to travel industry protection

CHOICE says moves to abolish a long-standing protection scheme, the Travel Compensation Fund (TCF),for travel consumers would leave many Australians high and dry when travel agents go bust. 

CHOICE is calling on Consumer Affairs Ministers from around Australia to reject the proposals in the Draft Travel Industry Transition Plan when they meet on 7 December.1

“Just yesterday, more than 5,000 passengers booked on cancelled ‘Athena cruises’ were told to contact the Travel Compensation Fund, with most believed to have paid 40% deposits,”2 says CHOICE head of campaigns ,Matt Levey.

“If the Fund is abolished, Consumer Affairs Ministers need to explain where they will direct people next time a travel company fails, recognising that one-third of travel expenditure is still done through agents, often for very expensive holidays,” says Mr Levey.

CHOICE has released a submission on the Draft Plan, arguing that the proposed changes fall well short of Ministers’ public commitment to “enhanced consumer protection”3 and are likely to leave travellers out of pocket.

The Draft Plan proposes that following the abolition of the TCF, consumers would rely on the ‘chargeback’ protections available with some credit cards, along with an industry accreditation scheme and travel insurance, arrangements which CHOICE, along with other consumer groups and parts of industry, believes are inadequate.4

“Chargeback is a piecemeal replacement for a compensation scheme because not everyone pays by credit card, and moreover, it’s wrong for governments to promote high-cost debt payments as a form of mainstream consumer protection,” says Mr Levey.

“Existing travel insurance products don’t cover the insolvency of travel agents, and there are doubts about whether such products would materialise if the compensation scheme was abolished.”

“Simply establishing an industry accreditation scheme, with no compensation fund, no prudential oversight and no consumer involvement, will do nothing to enhance consumer protection,” says Mr Levey.

CHOICE says that if Ministers decide to abolish the TCF or reform it to make funds available, they should provide funds to establish a national Travel Consumer Advocacy Centre. This would ensure ongoing assistance, unbiased information and advocacy for consumers.

“Experience shows that industry-run schemes work best with participation from well-resourced consumer voices, and if the fund is wound up, a portion of its reserves must go towards enhanced consumer involvement and advocacy,” says Mr Levey.

CHOICE’s submission to the Draft Travel Industry Transition Plan is available online.

Media contact:

Matt Levey, CHOICE Head of Campaigns – 0488 214 066

  1. See ‘Draft Travel Industry Transition Plan
  2. See ‘Athena Cruises Cancelled – Advice for Passengers’, 7 November 2012
  3. See Joint Communique, Ministerial Council on Consumer Affairs Meeting, Friday 3 June 2011
  4. For example, see the submissions from the Insurance Council of Australia, House of Travel and the Queensland Consumers Association



Related articles

Related tags:

Travel insurance buying guide

Are you paying too much to insure your holidays? Here's how to find a good deal on travel insurance.

1 May 2008 | This article helps you decide on insurance for international travel, tells you about cover and exclusions and gives tips about how you can save money.

Travel insurance review

Get to know your travel insurance policy so you don't find yourself stranded at home or abroad.

29 Jan 2014 | We review 22 brands of travel insurance and 89 policies in total, covering travel to Asia, Asia-Pacific, Europe and Worldwide.


Sign up to our free

Receive FREE email updates of our latest tests, consumer news and CHOICE marketing promotions.