Credulity squeezed by leaky juice health claims

Survey finds not enough extracts to make much difference.

Straight fruit juice sold in supermarkets can be just as good for you and cheaper than those which make health claims based on added extras such as herbal supplements or antioxidants, according to a CHOICE report.

The consumer group found juice promoting the likes of aloe vera, echinacea, ginkgo, ginseng, spirulina, barleygrass and wheatgrass did not contain enough of these extracts to be of any significant health benefit.

Many of the products which go by names such as Kickstart, Energy Lift and Green Recovery are mostly inexpensive apple juice with a few added extras, some of which verge on the ridiculous.

One juice from Berri which claims to contain “over 30% of your daily needs” of omega-3 fats for your “heart and mind” in fact contains only 8% of the Heart Foundation’s recommended daily dose (for men).

A serving also has just one percent of the beneficial fat that you would find in a 140g slice of Atlantic Salmon. Berri Superjuice Immune had just 16% of the recommended dose of echinacea and Kickstart only 3% of the recommended dose of ginseng and ginkgo.

However the low levels may be an advantage because the “natural” extracts at higher doses are not necessarily safe. Gingko can interfere with other medications such as anticoagulants (blood thinners) while ginseng should not be taken during pregnancy and only in small doses if you have high blood pressure

“In our view the use of medicinal herbs in products like juices should be banned unless specific approval is given after a proper safety assessment, an idea which our food regulator has abandoned,” said CHOICE spokesman Christopher Zinn.

Another concern is the promotion of extra antioxidants. Reliable studies find no evidence that taking antioxidants as a supplement provides a preventative health benefit for cancer or heart disease.

“Apple juice has only 14% of the antioxidant capacity you’d get from actually eating an apple. The juice market is rife with claims which are not matched by reality and it's often best to stick to the whole fruit or vegetable,” said Zinn.

Related articles

Related tags:

Bottled juice supplements

Are juices that contain extra antioxidants or supplements better for you?

26 Feb 2009 | Fruit juices with exotic supplements have spread from juice bars onto the supermarket shelves. But are these juices with feel-good extras really better for you than straight juice?


Sign up to our free

Receive FREE email updates of our latest tests, consumer news and CHOICE marketing promotions.