Choice. Make the right one.
Premium content

All-in-one printers review and compare 2010

Our 2010 update finds that a multifunction printer, while handy, can be expensive to run.
 

Sign in

  •  
  •  
 
 
 
 
 
 

01.Introduction

MFP-lead

Test results for 17 multifunction printers from $79 to $699

Multifunction inkjet printers (MFP) combine many functions into one device. It seems rare, however, that any multifunctional device does well at all its functions. We are now testing MFPs in Australia so our previous MFP test is not directly comparable to this one as the method for testing has changed slightly with more emphasis on their main functions.

We tested for:

  • Print quality and speed
  • Ease of use
  • Scanning performance
  • Copy performance

You might expect an MFP to have a financial saving on its side. We made a simple calculation of running costs in one year and found these devices can cost more than 19 times the initial purchase price.

It’s no surprise some people will choose to buy rather than refill their old printer. In our view, this is a direct consequence of the high price of ink. If prices were realistic, manufacturers could very well make a valid sustainability claim – but only provided they were willing to forgo a portion of the massive profits they make on ink.

It's not all bad news. Some MFPs we tested do a good job at almost all their functions. If you’re willing to foot the running costs, some can be worthwhile if you need a device for all occasions and in many cases come out ahead of buying a separate device for all the functions they have. Some of the more expensive MFPs also have neat features such as a touchscreen, wireless capability for access throughout the home, fax and memory card access so you can put the card from your camera straight into the printer without having to go through your computer.

For those who aren’t too fussed about the quality or speed of printing, there are a couple of bargains in the mix – see the comparison table. Consider the running costs as well as any lower initial purchase price.

Brands tested

  • Brother MFC-295CN
  • Brother MFC-6890CW
  • Canon PIXMA MP270
  • Canon PIXMA MP560
  • Canon PIXMA MX320
  • Epson Stylus Office TX610FW
  • Epson Stylus Photo TX810FW
  • Epson Stylus TX110
  • HP Officejet Pro 8500
  • HP Photosmart Plus B209
  • HP Photosmart Premium C309a
  • Kodak ESP 3 (A)
  • Kodak ESP 5
  • Kodak ESP 7
  • Lexmark Impact S305
  • Lexmark Interact S605
  • Lexmark Platinum Pro905
 
 
Your say - Choice voice

Your say - Choice voice

Members – Sign in on the top right to contribute to comments
 

Related articles

Related tags: Printers
 
 

Multifunction printers review and compare 2009

These all-in-one printers may save on space, but they tend to be expensive to run.

19 Mar 2009 | The printers combine inkjet printing, copying and scanning functions (some have fax) into one device.

Colour laser printers review and compare

Personal laser printers can colour your world, but watch out for hidden costs.

14 Dec 2009 | We bought 10 colour laser printers designed for the home and small office and tested for speed and print quality and also compared their ongoing running costs.

 

Wireless routers review and compare

Cut the tether to your broadband modem and wired network with these 10 wireless routers.

8 Jul 2008 | Wireless networking (Wi-Fi) lets you roam freely anywhere within the range of a wireless access point, also known as a 'hot spot'.

Budget laptops review and compare

We test 10 laptops that give you good bang for your hard-earned buck.

24 Aug 2009 | CHOICE tested 10 budget laptops that provide a good combination of power and features at a reasonable price.